has too on what I seen of the highlights ... put him reserves get his confident back.....completly out of position for the trys

who should play instead? Kevin Penny mk2?

Dropping him will give him a massive boost to his confidence wont it??? He made a couple of mistakes fair enough, were you asking for tom Briscoe to be dropped after the Wakey game???

Sharp bombed their first try fair enough. However the second try (?) they had about a 5 man overlap and Sharp was left totally exposed due to others being sucked in, and the good quick ball (remember them quick balls?) left Sharp in no mans land.

Should not be dropped, theres a couple of others in front of him who need dropping


And whilst i am at it. If the damm annoying woman who sits behind me in block e17 reads this his name is WILL SHARP not bloody PETER SHARP!!!

Long went flying out for the 2nd try and he was the nearest man to Sharp

Complete over reaction to Sharp's errors, was ok for the rest of the game and indeed the season so far.

I've said it before, but our inability to slide the defence to his wing and playing so bunched up is always going to leave him exposed. The best winger in the world would get caught out by our defensive tactics on that side of the field

Most of them weren't even his errors.

i dont agree with him been dropped but he has to improve defensively and basic drop balls but i also would like to see lynne given a few games here and there

Getting sick of hearing fans screaming at Sharp for letting a 3 man overlap score past him. Dont they get sick of shouting at whatever winger happens to be standing on our right had side?

more likely Agar will be dropped for the game

I can't believe Agar carries on with his policy of playing Long/Obst at right centre (in defence) the amont of tries been conceded on the right side of defence is criminal.

Will Sharp - The new Hull FC scapegoat.

Some people need to grasp the concept that Sharp is been left exposed on numerous occasions through no fault of his own. Our right side defence is poor and has been for years, I'm sure if stats were available then it would show our right side leaks the most points and I think we will continue to do so until we sign an out and out right centre instead of playing utility players there.

Imo sharp hasn't done much wrong, sure he has made some poor options but to contemplete dropping him is laughable, you don't hear the shouts for briscoe and whiting who have made poor decisions over the past few weeks.

This has been going on for at least two seasons, we cant play that sliding defence, unfortunately its Sharps turn to be blamed. Against Wigan with a man extra why didn't we play the old fashioned game of mark the man opposite you eg centre marks centre. we have a big pack we don't need to bunch like we do, decent quick half backs with a good pass and we are screwed, needs sorting out on the training pitch.

Thought that was Long.

He was to blame for everything before he even got here!

It was also sharp's fault when we leaked tries down that win last year

While we're on the subject of poor efforts on kicks, I seem to remember Whiting getting out-jumped by Rangi (the dwarf) Chase on Friday aswell.
Grounds for termination of contract if ever there was.

Briscoe had one bad game so dont see what the comparison is.. sharps been poor to average all season...i think he should be dropped.

A poor mans blacklock from what iv seen so far...hope he turns it around and proves me wrong but up to now im far from impressed...and im not making him a scapegoat by the way,theres a few that dont deserve to be in that 17 but we dont have the options to replace certain players...id give lynne a chance,reckon he could be a real star for the future.

Like some have said,youth players dont seem to be getting much of a chance these days and if we dont try them wel never find out!!

Do people really feel more comfortable with Lyne on the wing rather than Sharp?

How can you justify asking for someone to be dropped having appeared to have only seen a minutes worth of highlights?

He mis-judged the flight of a kick, knocked it on and was then sent to run behind the entire defensive line, in a race against Chase kicking the ball out there. If he's getting dropped for that then we'd start with about 3 players next week.

We knew when we signed him he is a bit of a loose cannon. He'll make errors but will produce some fine skill and can also guarantee you the work-rate every week. He's not done badly at all so far and as previously mentioned, is close to becoming a scape-goat.

Whiting to the wing when Gleeson comes in.

I'm with you on this ine Hutch, drop Long this week (at least) as well as Sharp

What a stupid statement.

How can you comapare the 2 players, Reece has been one of the top players in the country since he was 11, his main problem is strenght which will come with FT training, he is still very young and has only played a handful of games, Hull maybe rushed him and it doesn't help playing in a poor side.

He will make an excellent winger given time and the right coaching, much better than Penny.