Doesnt look good for Horne, which is abig shame fod him.

Massive massive game for shaul as a decent performance should see him start in the final.

It would only be his 6th first team game.

If Horne plays against Salford and comes through unscathed, he plays FB at Wembley for me.

Far less of a risk, Shaul has been good, but against three poor sides (at the time).

Agree fully. Unless Shaul has a brilliant derby, and then it presents a bit of a dilemma.

For me, it's Shaul's spot to lose. I'd be saying go out and make a name for yourself (in a good way!) lets hope PG has a very difficult decision to make and he gets it right.

Correct in my opinion. Shaul's time will come - it could be Wembley this year - but a fit Horney would have been selected in front of him at the start of the season and should be now.

That said if Shaul plays at Wembley I wouldn't be that worried about it and he should definitely play in front of RW at full back if that's the choice.