With the uncertainty surrounding Justin Morgans future at Hull kr Johns name keeps cropping up as a possible candidate to take over the role, it seems likely that you guys will drop into the championship next season ( a totally disgusting decision if true) do you think he will stay loyal and stick with you guys or do you think he will want to stay in sl and be tempted to coach us????

Noble to KR.

He is no longer the right man to take Wakey forward from where we are whichever league we are in. I for one would be delighted if he was appointed mid-term and you paid us a bit of compensation - we might start seeing some more entertaining Rugby at Belle Vue

I heard that MacNamara was leaving his post with England to coach HKR.

god help them lousy coach overrated player

Happy with a straight swap tbh.

I'd take Kear over any of the names mentioned above. He by by no means perfect, but even with significantly bigger budgets, only Noble has ever really done better.

I don't think any other coach could have done as well as we have with the current squad and because of this I think he deserves a shot with a big budget if we are lucky enough to stay in Super League but the pressure will be on for him to succeed and if he doesn't then we should look elsewhere.

Noble has got Cas job at end of year as matterson going bak to oz

Noble for HKR. Morgan for Cas depending if you get a franchise

Kear as seen us through awful times financially if we stay in SL and Mr Glover gives him his backing then the guy deserves a shot !!! Kear is still the man let him have money he deserves it !!!

You certainly like to go against the flow

When we get our new license I like to see Noble take over with Durey in the wings
fresh start

Did Duray coach the nines?

Tony was there and JK was in the dugout too so I couldn't tell you

I think you could give him all the money in the world but our tactic's would still be 5h1te

Slater.

What flows that then. The intelligent and knowledgeable fans who know Kear is the best coach we could have. This IMO is the majority.

or

The deluded fickle fools who think the grass is greener and are small in number and brain cells but big of gob.

Which is it?

You couldn't make it up, pure comedy gold



So he gets us 7 wins from a makeshift team with players that no one else would touch and his tactics are sh*te - the forum reaches new and ever lower depth.

I am a well voiced Kear detractor and I take issue with your comment above. Just because I don't think Kear is the right man for the job anymore and his tactics and team selections are baffling why does that make me unintelligent and not knowledgeable.

I have articulated my reasons for why he should go, you try and explain why you think I and IMO other intelligent and knowledgeable fans who share my view are wrong. Even TRB who is one of the few people on here you seem to respect has questioned the way we are being coached etc.. Are you now questioning his intelligence and knowledge?

Its 6 wins unless you are counting the cup win against a 2nd division side in Doncaster. We may have six wins but we have lost 4 of the 5 games we have played against the teams where we should have been pinpointing a win. The hard work in springing suprise results against Catalans away and Cas from a big deficit is wasted to some degree if you then get thrashed by a Harlequins team who haven't won in 13 games.

I despair, I really do - have you not noticed what's happened to the club, do you not read the team sheet - the fact that we have any points is a miracle.

Still I'll indulge you and I'm up for a laugh - who are these coaches who would have done better?

Oh and it's 7 wins unless cup matches don't count anymore

What a crock of crap, I know TRB personally and much as I admire his work for the club I would never consider him overly knowledgeable as regards the game and nor would he. His opinion is no more valuable than yours or mine, frankly your post has made me feel ill it's so fake.

Don't use another poster to make your point or put words in his mouth. TRB being unhappy with certain elements of our game does not equate to him wanting Kear gone.

Some posters on here seem to be suggesting they are in the majority regarding Kear not being the man for the job, I dispute that.

I'm all for Kear having a shot on full cap money, then if the results don't come, then let him go...

Why do I need to name a coach who could do better. You tell me where my arguments about us under Kear are wrong. There is a consensus amongst some of our intelligent and knowledgable fans that the players we have could do more than the mind numbingly boring 5 drives and a kick play which we have under Kear.

In addition, I view the fact that we seem to have issues with doing the basics right, picking the right players in the right positions, using the interchange bench properly as all things within the coaching staffs remit. Kear does not appear to be able to handle any of these areas correctly and has failed to address them.

I don't care what you say about the squad we have, there are some good SL standard players in it, including young players who have come from good rugby league environments (sts/wigan) and the sqaud can do more than they are doing in terms of playing, particularly in attack, if the coaching staff allow it. We also allowed one of our more experienced half backs to leave mid term (a decision ratified by Kear). Yes Jeffries may be inconsistent but he certainly would add something different if he were still here.

We need to attract new fans and will not do so playing so negatively and still losing by a significant margin.

Some of the points made above were also in TRB's comments on another thread. I will ask you again, in your opinion does that make him unintelligent and not knowledgeable.