my god you people are blind Smurph as tons more potential than Kermit ! Kermit is ok but Smurph is the future he can improve loads. Im sick of argueing with people like you who dont bother going to the games.

our signings = optimism = correct !! !
Dowes = average = correct !!!!! Do you think hes amazing pork boy???

I talk nothing but sense

Are you not the one who said that Dowes was more avergae than average?

Yawn.

Yes you do, non sense. You are a quarter wit

You talk nothing but shi1e

I thought garlic bread was the future? I'm confused.

Sorry I dont rate kirkmond every time I watch him he cocks up or gives a penelty away and thats why hes free to leave Huddersfield. As for Murphy whats all the fuss about happy for him to stay but if he wants to go no problem.

A wakey poster on the VT is saying Kirmond on a 3 year deal. Hope so.

I'm with "Get Em On Side Ref". He's only average (if that) and he really didnt want to play for us last time he was here.
I know we're not the richest RL club, but we dont want mediocre players. We'd be bettor off developing some youth.

It might have been a case of he would have rather played for Hudds last year, baring in mind that Hudds did well and got in the play off and beat Wire. Nothing personal against us. Just Hudds were in the bigger games and he wanted a part of that. Remember that Hudds got him off Fev so the lad has had to do it hard and work his way up.

In all honesty, we have

Souhern
Moriano
Johnson
Lauititi
Massellot
Spiers

Who can all play second row!

It is not a position we need recruitment in IMO.

If we are to do a deal then for a change we need to be getting the best of the deal! If we are going to offer Murphy out then offer him to other clubs and target players we want. If he's staying then let's move on.

On what authority do you have this, because I'm told he very much did want to play for us and enjoyed his time here - but that's just what I here and I can't guarantee it. You are entitled to your opinion regarding his ability but why add up stuff you can't prove to justify it?

Add Trout to that lot. The thing is though we need build a squad that is of overall a better standard to this year. In fairness Trout, Spiers and the Masselot are fringe players and need to play themselves in. Johnson and Ali may spend some time at prop. Kirmond may spend some time in the backs. So some of these players may spend time in other positions when tactics and injuries call for this. We need to build a group of players with some who can fill in when needed within the squad. The players who are signed/rumoured to be signing now are far better than the players we had in the season just past. So surely we have improved the playing staff in comparison to what we have just seen.

Kirmond is decent enough but if he does come it shouldn't be at the detriment of a couple more props assuming Hickey is staying, 3 if he isn't. S/R is not where we are weakest as it stands but that doesn't necessarily mean we shouldn't take on decent players when they come available, with the above proviso.

Sorry to jump in here on your forum but i spoke to Danny Kirmond when he returned from loan at Wakefield and he told me that he enjoyed his time at Wakefield while he was there and enjoyed playing for the club,i hope the rumers arnt true and he's staying at the giants because he always gives 100% even in bad games,a lot of people slate him for missing tackles etc,C'mon every player misses tackles and makes mistakes because they are human,if he becomes a wild cat then i wish him all the best,
Good Luck Danny where ever you play

I would be happy with Kirmond. I thought he was a good player when he was with us last time and I think he has a big future but has been held back by the overload of players in his position that Huddersfield have got.

I would also be pleased with Raleigh who I think is a very solid Super League player.

If we do swap Murphy for Raleigh and Kirmond then I think we will have got ourselves a good deal.

Radio version, brilliant episode.child Genius named simon if memory serves me correct played by doon McSomethingorother.

Quote ="inside man"Radio version, brilliant episode.child Genius named simon if memory serves me correct played by doon McSomethingorother.'" The full transcript s here if you're feeling bored. john-warren.co.uk/partridge/tran ... radio4.htm

Quote ="inside man"Radio version, brilliant episode.child Genius named simon if memory serves me correct played by doon McSomethingorother.'" The full transcript s here if you're feeling bored. john-warren.co.uk/partridge/tran ... radio4.htm

Quote ="kinleycat"The full transcript s here if you're feeling bored. john-warren.co.uk/partridge/tran ... radio4.htm'" I have them on mp3, think I will have a listen on the long trip to Carlisle in the morning. Cheers

Quote ="kinleycat"The full transcript s here if you're feeling bored. john-warren.co.uk/partridge/tran ... radio4.htm'" I have them on mp3, think I will have a listen on the long trip to Carlisle in the morning. Cheers

Is there any way i could get a copy of those please? Would certainly cheer up the journeys back and forth to Morecambe.

Just listening now, pm me your email address and I will get them too you as soon as I can but I'm in Carlisle till fri night with no internet.

I love it when Alan says to the Dad of the precocious child genius:

"John, do you ever sit alone at night by the fire, with your head in your hands and think to yourself, "God have mercy on my soul, I've spawned a monster!"

Classic.

Deal is sorted, just needs to put pen to paper

I'm happy about this - great lad with a good attitude. Was probably one of our best players when he was on loan here. Welcome back Danny.