I'm just listening to the London - Hull game on t'internet, and must confess to being very impressed with the commentary given by Craig Murdock.
It's very descriptive, thorough and informative. You can almost imagine being at the game as it's so good. OK, slightly biased to the away team, but as he's on the books of Radio Humberside, not to be unexpected.

Pity we've got no-one over this side of the Pennines who is anywhere in his league.

OK, hes an ex-player, but that's nowt to do with it... we've got Ray French



Are there any other commentators on the circuit that anyone "rates"?

I was listening to the first half on Wire FM, sister station to Wish FM.
The bloke doing the coverage, and I presume all Widnes games was excellent.
AS opposed to the bloke who does the Wire games, Graham Lovatt, I think.
He is beyond bad!
Immagine the same voice as Fred Elliot, the Butcher off Coronation Street for the voice, crossed with Stevo for the ridiculous element, wearing blinkers, blind, stupid, and possessing the sum total of RL knowledge of a pizza.
Now that is bad!

The lad who does the Widnes games on Wire FM is Joe Mills. He's actually a Wigan fan and up until this season was a season ticket holder at the DW.

Do we not? "Good Friday 2011 - Wish FM Commentary" on You Tube. Lovely stuff!

Conroy ?

On a slight tangent... summarisers! There's been some classics.
Funniest I remember was Carl Fitzpatrick on Radio Manc.
It was a game (between who, I'm not sure), but it was being played in poor conditions, with numerous knock-ons.
Early 2nd half, quote our Carl after yet another knock on " It favvers they've bin maulin' wi sum grayse arr eyf time"
Priceless!