Wild, Hodgson, Aspinwall, Brown and Robinson to be kept at Wigan I hope you were watching tonight.

I was watching, not that I wanted them back, Shudds were at 6s n 7s for best part of the game. Dodgy lived up to his rep and I didn't even realise Wild was playing!

Said the exact same to my dad. They proved why we let them go, as did calderwood!!

haha. I know, I was thinking about that and regretted it

Would still have Wild back although agree re the rest!

in place of who though??

i wouldnt put him before Hock, Hansen, Bailey, Tomkins, Mossop, or O'Loughlin.

Got to remember who that lot played with. There was Lam, Farrell, Craig Smith, Terry O;Connor, Mick Cassidy, Kris Radlinski.........experience counts for an awful lot. If only our side had that kind of experience this season.

I'd play him in the centres alongside Carmont

Please don't make me cry

Wild could play right centre or back row adding size and bulk something we haven't got in our back row.
He's also faster than any of our back rowers and probably centres too.

I'd go with that too. Always rated Wild, and was playing really well towards the end of his time at Wigan. Good centre, with good defence - and would swap him for Phelps, Goulding or Pryce tomorrow

All well and good providing you don't let them go and replace them with crap, and end up taking on make weights such as Phelps.

Pryce?

That would be an act of faith, swapping a never-was for a definitely-may-be (who also happens to be younger).

cant judge them on one game, hull are playing really well at mo. would the same question had been raised after they played catalans in round one. we'd have been begging for them back

Wild had quite a bit of pace too and a lot of heart and determination. Mike Gregory wanted to keep him but ML said we had to sell him to keep Adrian Lam IIRC. Saints have been sniffing around him while he has been at Huddersfield also.

He is a good player Steven Wild. Fortunately we are blessed with Second row/loose forwards so he isn't a major loss. Although I would still take him over Phil Bailey.

Huddersfield and those players played really well against us (saints) last week. I think last night was just a bad day at the office so to speak. I think Hudds will be up there at the end of the season when it matters.

Out of all the players on show last night who we've let go the only 2 i'd be interested in having back are Danny Tickle(who i've always rated very highly when on top form) and more suprisingly Kev Brown.

Brown has started the season very well and didn't do too badly last night. He looks to have matured quite abit and is getting his head down and working hard(i'll forgive him his one brain fart of a pass into touch).

Wild really suprised me last night with how lazy he was. He's been such a hard working player for Huddersfield these last couple of years but looked un-interested last night.

He had a nightmare of a game last night.

2 standout ex wigan players last night were Tickle & Brown

Said the very same to Bilko last night.

I thought he had a poor game tbh.

He didnt do nothing in play, just seemed like it cause eddie and stevo were creaming over his conversions so much