Yep

FFS! You come on here spouting again. So winning a 20th challenge cup in the year 2020 is nothing hey? Would you care to give your reasoning? I'm more than happy to have that particular discussion with you. Or do you save your anti-Wigan shoite especially for Redvee?

They need to win a 13th first

I quite like this comment:

"It's history because it's asterisk season. Only need 3 games to win the cup?"

They didn't manage 1 win in their cup campaign and are criticising how many are needed to go on and win it

There’s 1 person criticised it. Just 1.

Spouting?

Will you please stop putting words in my mouth. When have I said it’s nothing? I said it’s hardly “making history” as Rogues made out. If you win the cup it’ll be a great achievement, as is any cup final or GF win. I just thought Rogues was clutching at straws finding some link between the 20th cup win and the year 2020 that’s all.

This is the 2nd time you’ve taken something I’ve said and completely twisted it. Are you one of those people who just loses their heads when an opposition fan appears? Have a minute mate.

Correct decision. Well done Lam

Anyone care to have a guess at the 17?

Completely agree with the squad rotation - not convinced Hanley should have been put in. He's not ready yet in my view and it could be a big hit to his confidence if he has a really difficult game.

Rogues saw the marketing potential in Wigan winning in [ithis[/i particular year, while one of your peers tried to make a strange argument that two league points were more important.

It is when you've no chance of winning the cup. Again.

Let's be honest. Every single club would love the idea of winning their 20th title in 2020 just for the marketing potential but will laugh at any other club for saying it, especially us.

We'll murder 'em

Saints could always use 12 wins but not won it for 12 years.

If someone has claimed winning next Tuesday is more important than a potential Challenge cup final they’re extremely mistaken. Or in denial.

People in glass houses should not throw bricks.

Remember August 21st in 1976.

I do, Green VIgo seven tries.

Putting words in your mouth? And I quote: "Is that it!? •••• me" And you're complaining because I describe it as you "thinking it's nothing"? Far from putting words in your mouth, I'd say I was giving you the benefit of the doubt there.

The reason I jump on your posts has nothing to do with you being an opposition fan and everything to do with you being a hypocrite. It's funny how Brian is "the definition of an internet troll" (sic) when he posts anything on that cesspit you call a forum but you're being the voice of reason having cuddly chats with the nice Wigan fans when you post similar on here. It's almost as if you believe we couldn't possibly see the utter tripe you post on Redvee.

It's common knowledge what you think of Wigan. You've posted it often enough over there. If you're posting on here, don't water it down to try to paint yourself as something you're not. Stop being a hypocrite. It's nauseating.

Kind of a shame that Saints didn't get through their QF as you would have seen a more even and exciting contest tomorrow with both teams fielding academy teams. That being said, I'd prefer to play Warrington in the final than Saints IF of course we get past Leeds.

I dunno. Saints are stronger in weekly rounds but they do have a habit of losing the big games. I could see them going into the cup final as favourites and getting turned over as they did last year, but they choked well before then as it has happened.

Made it even better that they bottled it to the king of all bottlers

Yup..

So because I said “is that it?” in response to his tedious link between the 20th title and the year 2020, you interpret that as me saying winning the cup means nothing!? That seems reasonable haha. Of course winning the cup is huge and winning it for a 20th time is a great feat. You’ve completely taken my comment out of context; it was purely in response to Rogues claiming it was some sort of grand moment in history because of the year 2020.

I’m not paining myself as anything. I post the same way whether it’s on here or redvee. I try to be reasonable all the time. If you’re judging me on comments I made 10 years ago then maybe you need to realise people change/grow up. If you can find anything unreasonable or argumentative I have said recently then go ahead and pull me up on it. But until you can do that, pipe down and allow me to discuss things on here in a reasonable fashion. Currently, YOU are the only one being argumentative and causing problems.

FB 39 Hanley
RW 21 Manfredi
RC 3 Hankinson
LC 35 Halsall
LW 23 Bibby
SO 28 Smith
SH 27 Jake Shorrocks
P 14 Flower
H 32 Borough
P 19 Bullock
SR 15 Greenwood
SR 29 Wells
LF 20 Byrne

S 34 Pearce - Paul
S 36 McDonnell
S 37 Rushton
S 40 Kilner

Good shout, I wonder if maybe Halsall will start on the wing with Bibby at centre? Possibly Mitch Clark will feature somewhere in the 17 too. Really hope all six debutants get a run out. Am looking forward to this game even though anything other than a defeat is hugely unlikely