To be honest I haven't really seen any criticism on here, more from a few on the terraces and social media.

Whilst we don't represent anyone, I think that we are at least representative either way I don't recall much anti Brett stuff

When i say " non representative" ,i am referring to the small number who have commented on this article on this forum compared to the actual fan base.

Here's a question, if Brett had played in the final, what difference does anyone think he would have made?

I don't normally get involved in rumour and speculation but back in July my brother told me about Hodgson moving on at the end of the year and that Michael Monaghan had signed another year, Carvell and Morley both leaving. Some of them were no shock but I said that can't be right because Hodgson had another year to go and I didn't think we would give MM another year given injuries and lack of form at the time. Allegedly Hodgson had been giving it the big I am suggesting he needed to play if Warrington were to perform. Some of what he told me back then was true.

Great player in his day but Old Father Time had finally caught up with him...He's lost the pace he had which was exemplified at Salford when a break was made from a long way out and Hodgson gave chase but was pushed out of the way by Ben Currie who flew past him...He seems to be like an old time boxer who has been battered for 8 rounds and referee stops the fight. He pleads to be given one more round convinced that he will knock his opponent out in the next round...Brett's had a long and distinguished career but should now be honest with himself and retire gracefully. The smack in the chops vs Widnes didn't help.

Four pages in and no-one knows where or what he is doing next season. I loved him when he first joined and the way he just arrived on time to complement Briers or Myler in attack. He was some player with the boot too.

Agreed.
Incredible player and yes - the best full back we've had since Hesford and Whitehead IMO and I'm not sure then who would come out on top.

Derek Whitehead had the best side step I have ever seen!

I can understand not extending his contract given his age and he was probably on a good deal, but leaving him out of the last couple of games surely was because he was injured and not fit, no? If he was fit and able to play then I would be amazed if we left him out for games as big as these. I was disappointed when I saw he wasn't playing at OT but thought it was unlucky for him to miss out through injury...if he was just left out then thats a huge call and I can see why he would be annoyed and feel we were making a mistake.

I thought ratchford had earned his spot for them last fews games of the season...

This.

If you look on twitter, Myler tweeted a picture of his foot taken after the Huddersfield eliminator and it ain't pretty. I struggle to believe Smith would have made him play with it at Old Trafford unless he had to.

I'm not making out I've got some great inside knowledge in the club and am hesitant about saying this, but I did speak to someone within the club about Hodgson, expressing my surprise that he'd gone midway through his contract when he was one of my favourite players and someone who I'd hoped would stay to coach. The person was slightly more forthcoming than I'd expected, and said that Brett was something of his own man, but a lot of it family-driven - the example being not coming in to train when his child was ill, and missing the odd squad event, and that eventually it hadn't gone down well with TS. There was a suggestion that he still lived in Yorkshire (not sure if anyone can verify that?) rather than near Warrington, and was a bit detached.

That is interesting. He still lives in Huddersfield, although so does Smith and there are a few others on the other side of the hills. When you say about being detached though, I do remember him saying he didn't know where the town centre was and finding it rather odd.

Yes, the other example given was a quiz evening where in the past the Yorkshire players hadn't been expected to go but TS wanted them all to. I'm not sure if Brett did or didn't go to that particular thing but the suggestion was that he and TS had different views on that sort of thing

I heard that Hodgson had missed every training session during the play-offs.

In fact O'Brien was apparently training at full-back until he got injured. Those damn pesky injuries area right nuisance for sportsmen.

I hadn't heard anything about the rumours surrounding his departure and if true, what a sad way to end a glittering career and a sad way to sign off at Warrington where he'd been a fantastic signing.

I really hope it isn't true otherwise he's damaged his legacy which is a real shame.

rumours rumours gossip

at the end of the day if you're on the outside like we are all you can judge is what you see on the field and there were never any problems with Hodgson's attitude or his performances there

Yeah, if Brett had ever been anything less than 100% committed to the cause, he wouldn't have kept coming back after the punishment he suffered down the years. The truth may never be told, and of course the truth isn't as seductive as rumour, but the truth is the guys heart beat P&B blood every time he donned the shirt.

That's the way I'll remember him.

Surely the fact that every leaving playing was videoed thanking the fans ans answering question, but the only player who didn't have a video done was Hodgson, isn't that an indication that he left on bad terms?

Smith has previous for isolating big name players at the end of their career. Some years ago just after Smith took over at Warrington a well known ex Leeds prop didn't have an awful lot of nice things to say about smith for leaving him out of a Challenge cup final. I think it may have been the same final that Senior played on one leg.
I don't have a problem with the decision to leave Hodgson out of the squad. I don't think Fergie will be getting a Christmas card from a lot of ex Man Utd players.

I'm very much of the opinion if you turn up for 80 minutes a week and put a top notch shift in, that'll do.

As long as you're not a complete and utter disruptive nob that is.

If we were a part time club, I would agree with you. But the fact is Super League players are full time professionals and part of that is fulfilling various community and media commitments. Lets be honest, from the players I know they have an awful lot of spare time on their hands.

Cannot reiterate enough though that Hodgson is one of my favourite players to wear the primrose and blue, I hope we are completely wrong on this. Can only wish him all the best for the future and remember the many good memories he gave us at our club and elsewhere.

totally agree..and bert did and when the opportunity arose to meet him and the rest of the squad he was fantastic...i wish him all the best for the future