I was referring to size and speed. Was not comparing them to each other now, I believe there is more potential in williams than there is in penny.

I can't really argue against the Wow factor as Kev has really shown some tremendous performances in the past few years for the wire. All i can say is that when Kev turns up he really does turn up, when he doesnt then i would get a little bit worried. I would'nt be so worried if williams didnt turn up as his speed, strength and sheer size would counter that.

If you get what i mean?

You're more than welcome to send Williams back over the border to the Crusaders on loan while you make up your mind. We're in need of a bit of pace on the wing.

I know he's only young but for me I would make him Hicks replacement! He's fast, string and good defencivly! Just need some long term experiance and he will be good enough to start for me!

Sounds like you're describing williams to me

Rhys has looked like a rabbit in the headlights every time he's played, he might be quicker but there are other factors.

Penny has a better sidestep and better acceleration and always looks more likely to make a break than Rhys.

isnt Peter Fox great at those things as well .....? I was particularly impressed how he didnt drop any high kicks tonight when Saints put four bombs up for him.....
I dont suppose it counts as an error if your too Crap and $hit scared to get anywhere near any of them does it...

Peter Fox was defensively as bad as any proffesional ive ever seen play the game...and i'm sure you have stated he is a far far better winger than Penny on numerous occasions.....

clearly you dont understand the game which is reasurring when I have exactly the opposite opinion to you on everything to do with Rugby League