or just another false dawn for english rugby league, we seem to have a wealth of young talent coming through at the moment but will these players be given the chance or will we stick with the tried and tested? Just off the top of my head...all good young players

1.Riley
2.Hall
3.Lawrence
4.Shenton
5.Ainscough
6.Tomkins
7.Myler
8.Burgess
9.Houghton
10.Prescott
11.Tomkins
12.Kirmond
13.Westerman

cue lots of 'not international class' type comments.

Sink or swim, only one way to find out - the alternative of the same old guard clearly haven't and will never work...

Huby is only 22-23, Kirk Dixon is 24

I'd say from this year alone Huby is better then Prescott, and Cudjoe is twice the player Riley is, I'd go for something like:

1. Cudjoe
2. R. Hall
3. Shenton
4. Lawrence
5. Owen
6. S. Tomkins
7. Myler
8. Huby
9. Lunt
10. Prescott
11. Burgess
12. Kirmond
13. Westerman

Typical bleedin' Northern oiks...

Add Clubb, Sharpe and McCarthy-Scarsbrook to that list and it looks a bit better

Agree, especially on Clubb, despite his inability to grow chest hair - typical southerner...

Meh. Shenton is miles better than Clubb tbh. Sharp seems to be going backwards (many are citing a lack of confidence); i'd take LMS over Huby and Prescott.

LMS completely skipped my mind, so lets stick him on the bench for impact

That lot haven't particularly impressed me. For everything Riley does well like his stunning try at Bradford he does something daft like the knock that gave Bradford a try in the same game. He's a Paul Wellens type for me, lots of effort but not the kind of pure athlete the Aussies and Kiwis have in their backlines. I don't watch Leeds much but Ryan Hall has never stood out either, he doesn't look quick enough to keep up with Keef.

Ainscough is quick and a decent finisher but like Mick Potter and Brian Noble I am not convinced he'll ever be a reliable player, dodgyness is often a curse that remains through a players career. Mr Penny at Wire is a good example, he is the best finisher in SL and the quickest, but he looks unlikely to make it in SL at the moment, never mind on the international stage. Prescott is a poor man's Bryn Hargreaves and the 'other' Tompkins looks like he's only there as he shares a surname with the more talented pixie. To be fair to him I've not seem him play much.

Another nomination for this is Scott Moore. He looks to be the form hooker in Super League this season.

Behind Chad Randall you mean

Chalk and cheese. Clubb is putting on about a stone a week this season (

).

Has all the makings of a fearsome prop with plenty of pace and a decent sidestep.

How far down the line are we talking here? I mean Shaun Briscoe (25) and Peter Fox (24) are still fairly young with a good few years ahead yet.

I would add Peter Fox to that and you have Kris Welham pushing for a starting berth.

The only thing I've seen Randall do this season is that bizarre betting slip in back pocket pass to enable Quins to throw away a well earned victory.

I have been keeping a close eye on Clubb and i feel that is what is wrong with him he is building him self up to much making him to slow and same with our player Owen he seams slower this year because of his size.

allied to Scott Moore and the other two Huddersfield players i think Shaun Lunt and Danny Kirmond would be in with a shout if they keep developing the way they are.

I was thinking under 21, apolgies if some are older in that list.

How anyone could leave out Tom Briscoe and Louie McCarthy-Scarsbrook is beyond me.

The team should be:

1.Chris Melling
2.Tom Briscoe
3. Chris Lawrence
4. Michael Shenton
5. Ainscough
6. Joel Tomkins
7. Richard Myler
8. Sam Burgess
9. Houghton
10.Prescott
11.Sam Tomkins
12 Danny .Kirmond
13.Joe Westerman

Bench: McCarthy-Scarsbrook, Worrincy

I think he'll make a damn fine second row.

Chris Melling

Luke Robinson and Kevin Brown are only 24.

If you got any more bitter you could swim in your own bile.

He just doesn't do it for me, decent player don't get me wrong but theres just something about him.

isnt Prescott Irish?