You asked which club has had it roughest over 30 years, in my opinion my club has from the examples i gave......if you had asked which clubs fans have seen the least number of trophies won/semi finals contested then it would not have been mine.

And no i wouldn't swap because in those dark days i had some great times and met some wonderful people ....it wasn't and still isn't all about winning things to me otherwise i would have been a Bradford or Leeds fans by now !!

Wakefield have had their cup finals - relegating Cas twice and then the million pound game last year. I'd suggest they've had more lucky escapes than many other teams have had enjoyable seasons. Teams like Salford haven't had anything to crow about over the last couple of decades. They've had the relegations that Wakefield haven't had and zero finals/lucky escapes - that's much rougher than constantly magicking yourself out of relegation as Wakefield have managed season after season.

So in SL, Salford have probably had it worse than Wakefield. Outside of SL you can take your pick - every team (with the exception of Bradford) have had it rougher than Wakefield. If Wakefield had ever been relegated, maybe their fans would appreciate that rather than whinging about constantly being the bottom feeders of SL.

The thing is, it’s nigh on impossible to quantify as there isn’t a points system of say, +10 for winning a major trophy, or -5 for a relegation.

You’ve mentioned all the tough times at Huddersfield, whereas I haven’t bothered, there’s been too many, but at least yours are a thing of the past…

But at least you’ve admitted you wouldn’t swap places, whereas I would trade my team playing in a lower division just to have witnessed just one success, & as for the changing teams thing, well that’s just wrong & people who do have no soul.

Oh yes, that’s surely up there with a C.C. final.




Ever been relegated, I’ve seen loads, the best one being when they changed the goalposts halfway through a season

.

Well, sorry but you did post the question and i answered it with my opinion.

I realise obviously you were after people agreeing with your post but i didn't.

Wakefield are having hard times now but again until they hit the rock bottom of the entire RL like we did then, in my opinion, there is still no comparison....

Huddersfield.
no other club has spent decades out of the top flight like we did, playing in front of a few hundred die hards in a crumbling ground, not knowing if it would be the last time you'd ever watch them! Wondering if the club would go bust every morning,losing out 3 generations of supporters.

then finally we made it back, slowly but surely, then we were out of our depth for 4 years, getting walloped every week,finishing bottom every year, but not being demoted due to the ground grading regulations. again, losing a generation of fans.

the merger!

to put it simple, we could only dream about playing the top flight clubs, let alone competing and beating them.
how many other fans can say that playing against and losing games to the likes of Bramley, Chorley, Springfield/Trafford, Runcorn, Highfield et al became the norm.

so yes, Huddersfield

Wakefield won the Yorkshire cup when we were a 3rd division side happy to just scrape through a preliminary game against Nottingham City!
Wakefield were a well regarded top flight club for the first 10 years i watched Huddersfield, all those years we were in the 2nd or 3rd division.
the biggest game i attended in the first 5 years of watching Huddersfield was a yorkshire cup tie against........Wakefield trinity, so big that the crowd was qaudruple what we usually attracted.

we also got smashed 9-52, but yeah Wakey have had it worse

OBSESSED


Please explain how we are 'up and down relegation wise' as that is quite simply the ramblings of a lunatic.

Of all the things that are very rugby league phenomenons staking a claim to be the crappest club in the league is maybe the rugby leagueiest of all of them,

Well my post was referring to a 30 year period (as the original poster asked for) since both of our teams were decent in the mid-80s as I said and in that time you lot were relegated in 89 was it? I think promoted the year after and went back down a couple years after that and then back up in 2006 so yeah up and down. We were as well but I didn't say we weren't so yeah I might be a lunatic but I don't just say stuff without any basis whatsoever.

Stop whinging. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_d ... bs#England

Stop whinging. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_d ... bs#England

Cloud. Cuckoo. Land.

If you don't think that a few relegations and promotions constitute up and down then I'm not the one in cloud cuckoo land. KR were in the third division in the late 90s (was it 96/97? Might be wrong) so you weren't relegated to get into that division which is DOWN and then promoted which is UP? Duh!

Keep clutching at those straws

It's time the Hull clubs were merged.

I agree. So should Bradford/Leeds, Wigan/Leigh, Cas/Wakefield/Featherstone, Warrington/Widnes etc. FWIW Hull were merged......................................with Gateshead Thunder!

Another Hull bitch-athon !! is there a thread that doesn't get hijacked by these lot ??