www.mirror.co.uk/news/top-storie ... -21204347/

www.mirror.co.uk/news/top-storie ... -21204347/

Interesting. That would probably tempt me back into the 90s for an evening.

When i saw Ian Brown 3 years ago second song IIRC was I wanna be adored and the place went mental!

getting the 4 back together would be awsome!!!!!

even if they are all Dirty Reds!

Aren't you a plastic Liverpool fan?

Will they fall out and cancel at the last minute like at Glasto 95?

They were crap live anyway, Brown's voice was awful IIRC. Hope he's had some singing lessons if they're coming back.

If they do reform I hope they lay off the John Squire guitar w@nkfests from the Second Coming.

you dont have to have the voice of Kathrine Jenkins to bring joy to peoples ears

Don't get me wrong I like the albums "The Stone Roses" and "The Complete Stone Roses" but IMO they weren't anywhere near that standard live due to Brown's voice.

For those of us of more discerning taste we get joy from listening to singers who can actually sing.

Some bands whilst very good on a recording are gash live.

Oh another reunion.



Brown and Squire must be definitley skint now. Lets face it they've managed a couple of records in 20 years, then churned out Greatest Hits and Remix records. I was never bothered about them. And this reunion is not appealing whatsoever. I expect a dull record, full of the cut-offs from the aforementioned solo careers. I also think it will be as relevant and as successful as the Sex Pistols 'come-back'. The Roses had a famous and succesful Second Coming, I can't see them having a Third.

I don't think they will be doing any new material. Just cash in on what they've done and leave it there.

Remember the original line up have never played anything from the Second Coming live together.

I don't like rock/indie music but the first Roses album was classic - possibly the finest album of its genre.

As in most bands it is the rhythm section ie mani/reni that make that band - reni is the most underrated drummer of his generation - the Roses makes the bands Loz and his mates listen too seem what they are vacous non entities.

Cracking band, never got to see them live so would definitely go see them.

My sister went to Sheffield last summer to see Ian Brown and he did 2.5 songs fell off stage and spent the rest of the night in A&E.

Are you sure? - I saw them live at Sheffield and they played stuff from the second album - although maybe reni wasn't in the line up not sure

Wasn't the original line up. Honest. Reni left after the album was released and before the tour started.

Should be good. Maybe there music would be better in smaller venues can't see it sounding so great in the massive arena's.

I'll get to one of the gigs though!

Mersey Paradise



Sally Cinnamon

How Bizarre, those are my top Roses tunes!

How Bizarre wasn't by the Roses, it was by OCM.

Shut up Ferrino.

Not A Fan To Be Honest Never Got The Whole "Manc" Scene...
Stone Roses,The Smiths, Happy Mondays Or Oasis...

As I posted on the Sin Bin, so what if IB is out of tune a lot. He is f***ing class (for a Manc

). Blackpool was a cracking night (had it's moments after), heard a tape months later, f***ing awful.
As was posted earlier, when IB plays I Wanna Be Adored the place goes mental and rightly so.

Were you born when the Stone Roses were around?

Yes I Was Born By The Time They Released There First Album...
Maybe You Had To Be Around At The Time To "Get It" But I've Never Known What All The Fuss Was About To Be Honest...

any spike island attendees on this board?

Now thats a tune!