Yep, proper Knuckle Draggers

Probably but you could argue both have had an easier job in the sides they play in. I would argue Roby and Buderus are more influential for their current teams than Monghan is.

Roby has - at times - carried that Saints pack this season IMO.

However, if Warrington go on to win the Grand Final I wouldn't be surprised to see a Dream Team packed with Wire players.

I'd argue the opposite. Monaghan makes Wire tick, and they don't look anything like the same team when he doesn't play.

I always feel when playing Saints if you can stop Roby you've won half the battle. With Wire I would argue Briers is that person and is much more important to them.

Last year?

Re Donald V's Broughton/Jones-Bishop/Watkins, that was a discussion from 2009 regarding 1st grade options for 2010.

I've moved on from then as first Broughton and then Donald left the club (making any further discussions about the decisions taken - whether right or wrong - somewhat pointless) but I'll still engage with posters who wish to remember those discussions if they choose to instigate them - only not at such length anymore.