Quote ="eels fan"Yes in many many ways.'"
In your Opinion.
Quote ="eels fan"Before the SL war, RL had a national comp, now we have an East Coast League only.'"
So? I take it the East Coast league stole all the players, club houses, kids, supporters and ball when they formed did they? National Competition is well and good, but if the fans/cash was aren't there to sustain it, it will die.
Quote ="eels fan"RL was also shown on FTA TV nation wide each and every week on the ABC'"
Every game?
Quote ="eels fan"Now we only get nation wide coverage on Pay TV and yet sometimes they still stuff around and put other sports on if something pops up.'"
...nothing unique here...it's the same with all leading sports all over the world.
Quote ="eels fan"The very rare occasions we get FTA exposure these days nation wide, no one knows it's on as ch9 will not promote the game, they don't even promote it in the heartlands, they plug fumbleball non stop.'"
....again, so what? TV Channels have their own agendas...there is no god given right to watch sport on FTA TV.....
NB: The last 2 points show that you have a real dislike of PPV TV.....but it is the way of the world. You really do get nothing for nothing in this world.
Quote ="eels fan"The media gave the code nation wide exposure and we didn't have any of the muck raking BS that's been going on since 1995.'"
I have done a quick scan of todays Australian Media on-line.......and yes, AFL gets more inches in places where it's more popular....hardly shocking stuff is it?
Quote ="eels fan"All channels would at least put the scores up during their sports reports, good luck getting even ch9 (the rights holder) to do that in WA, SA and sometimes Victoria (who actually have a team).'"
Again, this is a nothing point......TV will show what they want, when they want...look at all this reality TV that's clogging the systems at the moment.
NB: After trying to bag PPV TV you are jow having a go at the Media in general.........but I have yet to see a reasoned argument other than the national comp isn't fully national any more.
Quote ="eels fan"The radio rights are a joke where we have idiots like Roy Hardley talking about truck horns, belly button fluff or cooking with old ladies instead of calling the football, yet there used to be heaps of different stations you could listen to to get your fix.'"
I was looking forward to debating on the subject of RL......but all I am getting from you so far is that you don't like the Media in general because they don't show what you want, when you want it.
Quote ="eels fan"The NRL actually allows ch9 and certain radio stations to blackout whole parts of the heartlands so Pay TV can get more people signed up, and forget about nation wide coverage.'"
MEDIA does not = Rugby League
Quote ="eels fan"Is this good?'"
Honestly? No. All you have done is point out that some teams don't play in the NRL that did play in a national comp before Murdoch got involved. No different to any other sport really.
Quote ="eels fan"Before the SL war, RL was the first code to get 100 million in Australia, that blew the AFL away and Union was still played by doctors and lawyers so it got a game a week on the abc like it does now.'"
Er...I think you'll find the doctors and lawyers game has built itself up as a pro sport all on its own and that has SFA to do with the SL War....more to do with economics and who you know.....
Quote ="eels fan"Soccer was still a basketcase..'"
....and it isn't now because of the SL war? Er, OK.
Quote ="eels fan"If Murdoch and Packer hadn't had the war and all parties done the right thing, that Billion $$$ we are hopefully getting in 3 years time would've been reached 10 years ago.'"
In your opinion and to be honest, I think you're losing the plot big time if you think that. Football, Hockey, Baseball and Basketball in the States are where the money trends come from, then global wendyball......but if it makes you feel better, carry on saying it.
Quote ="eels fan"Money was going up before the SL war, the players were going to get it regardless, so imo, you are wrong there.'"
So, did a player in pre SL war earn as much pro rata as a player now? Best way to test this is to judge how much a Dentist earned in 1990 compared to a pre RL player, then compare them now. I would suspect that dentist would pull their own teeth out nowadays to get Billy Slaters wage
Quote ="eels fan"On Pay TV only and as the number 1 sport by a country mile, it gets payed less than the AFL, the code was also removed from Foxsports # 1 channel for the AFL.'"
MEDIA MEDIA MEDIA MEDIA....where's the RL in this reasoned debate?
Quote ="eels fan"We get wall to wall coverage of AFL though on FTA.'"
...and in other countries, the lesser sports are the one shown on FTA.....
I have a question for you:
Q: Is it that you can't afford a satalite dish and decoder that you are this bitter towards PPV TV?
Quote ="eels fan"We could watch a few games back before the SL war on TV and it cost us nothing to do it, these days it's around a $100 a month for the privilege.'"
.....
Ah...you've answered my question wuith a big resounding YES
Quote ="eels fan"We also had plenty more news in the papers with Sydney having it's own RL paper, others sports didn't get a mention without it being something big, these days you get every sport.'"
did your mum run of with the paperboy? Your hatred of Media is quite worrying
Quote ="eels fan"You're kidding aren't you, three teams just this week asked for 1.6 million to help pay players and other costs.'"
and the cash is there to help them......unless you think that the 1 billion for tv rights next time is just balls.
Quote ="eels fan"The AFL and Union seen us more as a threat back then than now as now we have our hands tied behind our backs by Murdoch and Ch9 with not a pot to piiss in to expand, if RL was as good now as it was before the war, why was the ARL able to expand whenever it wanted back then, had millions in the bank it used to fight the SL war and had enough money to prop up teams that needed it, and advertise the game nation wide?'"
Lastly, you finaly come to RL......it's taken a while, but here we are. Problem is, you don't offer any quantifiable proof that RL was considered more of a threat back then, you spit bile about C9 and Murdochs empire (seek help with the media hatred thing BTW). You then go on to talk about having money to advertise nation wide.....er, you do know who owns the routes to market you would need to advertise don't you? Murdoch
Basically I have just wasted 20 minutes ripping your non argument to shreds.
You dislike having to pay to watch NRL........you hark back to the days where you got a couple of games a week on free tv......so progress isn't your friend is it?
You hate the Media because they won't show what you want, when you want it and for free.....
I have a tip.......buy MYSKY+ or whatever it's called over there. Yes...it costs money, but you can watch what you want when you want.....and 2 out of three aint bad.
Quote ="eels fan"The game has been held back now for 15 years while every other code has had a leg up from this same Murdoch mob, Murdoch and Packer lost a shhiitt load of Money on the AFL last time they had it together, guess where all their profits from Pay TV came from?'"
....earth to eels.....murdoch/packer don't run charitable organisations. Neither do they bite the hand that feeds.......they will continue to pay top doallar for sport so long as it sells dishes and advertisers like usinf their channels when it's on.........it ain't brain surgery...it's called business.
Quote ="eels fan"Yep, RL, and RL is still being under paid by these same visionaries.'"
Define underpaid? Oh, you mean the money available to other codes to spend on players wages........yeah....that's all the fault of Murdock and packer.
Sports that don't have a cap are in for a big fall in the future......even wendyball clubs the size of Barcelona are feeling the pinch...the cap is for the good of the game in the long run, not to keep murdochs expenses down
Quote ="eels fan"We all want that, but have you noticed all the IC talk in the media has News LMD pulling the strings still and making the IC is on their terms and their terms only?'"
so the independent bit needs to be dropped and just call it a commission.......FFS, Without Murdochs money the game would be reliant on gambling machines....and that's not a sustainable business model.
Quote ="eels fan"Good enough
'"
No....all you have done is bag the media (and badly at that). It's easy to blame hate figures for failings in the game (see wigans fans love affair with Mo Lindsey for proof of that), but in truth, EVERY MAJOR SPORT THAT SKY/FOX/ESPN etc have got involved in is wealthier (pro rata) than before.....every single one. Sport needs TV/TV needs sport and regardless of your opinions (pretty short on facts btw), the ARL/NRL's problems are their problems, not the AFL/ARU or the wendyballers.
I am sure that grass roots RL is suffering as a result of the SL war........but as a professional sport and BUSINESS it is better off....and like it or not, that is a fact. You can blab on and continue to add your opinion to the debate, but PROFESSIONAL RUGBY LEAGUE is better off for SKY/FOX TV's involvement financially. If you want to discuss if they are morally better off, then start another thread