I feel this needs its own topic, ive posted this on the other forum

Right i am going to post something that will upset a few, not bothered. This guy is 100% not the answer. He has very little ability and has zero effect on any game, York in pre season or last night. He has to be the worst half in Super League. I will put this to you, IF Rovers were to release him from his contract name 1 S.L team or a good championship team who would take him?

Anthony Thackray
Martyn Ridyard
All of Leighs H/B`S
Stan Robin
John Ford
Cory Aston
All of Toronto`s H/B`s
Scott Murrell

I would have any of the above in front of him. Even Dominic Bloody Brambani has more organizational skills than Marsh. Sorry but me and my family spend thousands of pounds a season to support this club, and people in the East Stand concur that things need altering.

I'd put Atkin in front of him Sheens obviously sees something in him what that is I don't know but your right he's not the answer I remember his debut and he was great that day but not since

Hard to argue with that. Think there was a good performance v Widnes in 1st middle 8s? Looked ok at fullback but yes at SL level he looks out of depth at half.Saying that he has behind a mostly beaten pack so hasn't had the luxury of time and space . Atkin looks the superior of the two from the stands

Yes it was at Widnes

I have not seen much of marsh but what I have he is not what we need he should be ok in the lower divisions not with us so we should tell him to get on is bike now

Have to agree, i hate to slag players off, but there was no link, Maguire looked stranded... if The said players name wasnt on the back of his shirt, i wouldnt have known he was out there.

McGuire needs a half back partner that (1) can create(2) is elusive, or(3) is fast.. but needs to be at least two of these things..All players have their level, and unfortunately he currently doesn't have a partner for what is required, and the team is suffering because of this.
Like others have said, I don,t like to have a go at players, BUT, we can see were we are lacking, but for one or two,this level is too high for what we need and we need someone else, and quick...harsh but true.
PS. What happened to the Luke Page rumour, oh yeah, it was just another bloody rumour..disappointing. We could do with an aggressive runner like him.

I agree 100 percent. I've seen enough of him to make me realize that he is not and never will be a good half back in super league in my opinion. The longer he goes on been picked, the more fans are going to wonder just what the plan is .

I think the continued search for a half back we are currently doing in the pubilc domain highlights that TS doesn't think he is the answer either.

I think there are concerns about atkins defence - which i agree with. He gets ran over too much. However, he brings an excellent kicking game and can run at the line, for that reason alone he should be in and defensively stick him out on the wing and jam in carney and minns, they should protect him