Have heard a couple of rumours from FC fans that we have signed him on a 5 year deal. Anyone else know anything or is just it that!?

Since when have Rovers ever given out 5 year deals?

Wouldn't be too impressed if we have. Chester has specifically tried to weed out bad eggs. Shaul seems to have an attitude problem

Cost you a pretty pen to buy him out his contract

I would have Dixon over Shaul any day. Shaul can't even get a game and is kept out of the squad by a player who doesn't even want to be at FC. The kid looks too arrogant to me. Stick with Disco dancing Dixon. He will be even better next season.

Swap deal for kelly I heard

You wish

I'd swap him for shaul but not sneyd

Still don't think sneyd is anything more than average thought Abdul controlled the game last night

Why would you want one of our fullbacks? You've got that kid who does the Macarena haven't you? Got rid of Eden for him! Haha.

Sneyd has it all but is inconsistent and we've been rudderless in most of the games he's missed this season. Swap him and kelly last night and you'd probably have won

Kelly without his injury and we'd possibly have also won. But we didn't so it's a futile discussion.

Rumour has it he's parramatta bound (b grade )

Absolute idiotic statement sneyd isn't a patch on Kelly
Kelly has been a stand out performer on his own all season take him out of our team and we would be terrible (we are just poor atm) if he played behind your pack he would be man of steel

Regarding shaul I heard last week a 3 year deal thats why i asked the question about him on there board

I think he's a prime example of how 'focusing on local talent' can be a two-edged sword. Radford indulged his reluctance compete for a position elsewhere in the team, if he couldn't get in at full back. Binned off an injured contracted player to facilitate it. Reports about his not giving his all on dual reg iirc, too.
Then, if this is true, he wants to jump ship? Hmmm.

You reckon? I think he's a great player but none of what I've seen from him has suggested he has any real organisational skills or much of a long range kicking game. Take those away from Hull last night and we'd have capitulated as we did at wakefield

I don't remember sneyd doing much except for your 1st try the fat lad kicked us to death, if you put Kelly behind your pack he would rip teams apart

And yet he's kicked more 40/20 than your full team put together

Oh well he must be a great long range kicker but decided not to bother last night then

He played on one leg his kicking leg was useless

sneyd is a class act, hes not a Kelly whos a also a class act and atm a better player but I think sneyd will get better and better

Imo not that it means anything but if you had a quality half (like Kelly) you would be right up there sneyd and Pryce really don't do much at all your pack has been class all season look at the 1st derby at your place for instance you made so many easy yards but in final third you just fell apart and i bet the same could be said for at least 5 more games this season with a good half you would of been 10 points better off

Pointless debate really though because we will never know and I'm probably getting into the Kelly is better than sneyd debate because that's all we have to cling onto because the rest of our team are revolting

no debate I already said Kelly atm is a better player,i also believe sneyd is getting better and better and we are far a better team when he plays