Just watched yesterdays game again and thought it would be interesting to get comments from both sides on info I took from game, the refereeing was abysmal to say the least I know I will get flack from Hull FC fans but this is a true reflection on the game and Thaylors one sided refereeing he has always been the same since Justin Morgan criticised him and got fined for it.

Forward Passes Hull FC -12 Spotted 1 - Tries scored 3
Rovers - 4 Spotted 2 - Tries 0

Penalties Hull FC - 6
Rovers - 5

Obstructions in Lead up t o Try Hull FC - 2

There were other items but I had been sickened off by then

To summarise if you take away the 18 points Hull FC Scored off forward passes then Rovers Should have won the game

After this conclusive analysis, we were clearly robbed and should be awarded 2pts.

Problems with mathematics seem as bad as your myopia.

If you took away the 18 points scored by Hull FC then the best Hull KR could hope for would be a draw

Oh deary me. This has got to be on of the most embarrassing threads for Hull KR fans in a long time.

You can literally hear them cringe!

You can have all the stats you want we got beat and nothing will change lets move on

You are Stevie Wonder and I claim my £5.

I like it, think we should do one of these for every game, much more entertaining then the game itself.

It wasnt obstruction because the Rovers player actually went for the tackle - you see his arms wrapped around the players. As for the rest, laughable really

Come on Craig just admit you lost it fair and square, now stop sulking, you'll feel better if you smile

All I am trying to do is point out the fact that Thaylor has it in for Rovers and apart from that the standard of refereeing is at the lowest standard I have ever seen in my 50 years of watching rugby league if this embarrass rovers supporters then I am sorry, it just goes to show that most people who watch the game now do not know what they are watching.

Great to see the bitterness stretch to a second day for some.

I demand a replay!

Penalty on half time - with Hodgson laid on Ellis - you get the penalty and kick at goal.

2nd half, Arundel adjudged to be laid on the defender and told to get up.

Yeah he really has it in for you

The only person who's struggling with what happened yesterday, is you mate.

1 spotted forward pass for FC = 1
2 spotted forward passes for KR = 2

Not sure where 12 and 4 come from. Unless you're going by the number of shouts of "forward" from the East stand. In which case 112 would be more accurate.

Are the "obstructions" included in the penalty counts? If not then they aren't obstructions.

And it's Thaler.

And if you take of the 2 points Rovers got from the penalty they were awarded when Ellis got pinged for interfering (I belive there was a rovers player sat on him at the time that impeded his ability to move out the ruck area) Rovers would still have lost.

Got to love bilge like this, just brightens up an already lovely sunny day!

I haven't laughed so much since I stopped reading the Beano!!

Top marks that man.

Lock it.

90% of Dobson's passes to the left edge are forward but let's forget those shall we



Most forward pass yesterday was Burns to the ground about 5 yards in front of Gleeson which was ignored.

As was Burns launching a punch at Shaul when getting up to play the ball under our posts. THALER ignored it. You got a penalty for Miller being offside and scored on the next set.

Cheer up Craig

Yes but if Mr Shaul had decided to go out with the lads instead of having a fumble on a bench in West Park with the missus, then young Jamie wouldn't have been conceived and hence the try yesterday would never have been scored.

The above statement I made sounds a more plausible excuse for losing then what the OP has said. I do cringe at some of the rubbish my fellow Rovers fans post sometimes.

So last weeks edition was your last then

Well said. We all have them though. Gives everyone a chuckle, mind you.

Wow that's some response. I'm mortally offended.

Oh dear. You conceded 32 points in a single half. A ref will never ever be that bad that he'll be responsible for 32points in 1half! Get a grip.