We've had some bad ones in my 35 years or so watching the club but these 3 really stick out for me. Who is your worst coach?

Is it possible to add other names to that list?

I'm not old enough to remember all our rubbish coaches, but in terms of the potential of the club during the coach's tenure and the percentage of that potential achieved, it has to be Agar by a country mile.

Not voting until you put Peter Sharp on the list. Just didn't like him or his attitude, regardless of his results.

Depends who it is

I want to vote for John Kear because he is ugly.

Great with his fingers though

How can you have Sharp on the list and not Tony Gordon? Sharp's recruitment was patchy but he did sign Manu and Tickle. Aside from getting to the Grand Final we had that run of 17 wins in 18 games which we can only dream of now.

As for the poll - it's Agar of course.

Aye The Tank should have been one of the first names on the list.

Its between Walsh and Agar but Agar tips it because of what he has its disposal and the cack he serves up.

How can anyone forget how bad Len Casey was , he was the closest reason ever i have been to giving it all up

He is the worst for me.

Worst probably but he only lasted 5 minutes and the club was skint at the time. i doubt any coach would have had a worse record than agar given all of the advantages he's had

Can I take a guess as to what your vote is?

No

Peter Sharp..gettin rid of some of our best talent the guy was a fool.. and an AHole.

Pretty amusing how some people seem to think a coach who took us to 2nd and a grand final then 4th and a playoff win is somehow worse than a guy who has served up unadulterated dross for nearly 4 years now. Makes you realise how effective the club's spin machine is on certain types of people.

Its the only time in my 32 years watching I actually stopped going to any games.

It is amazing. Sharp let himself down with some recruitment such as Maiava and Byrne, but he deserved a longer run in 2008 given what had happened in 2006 and then 2007 despite losing Cooke through no fault of his own. Looking at some at the results under him in 2008 - 29-30 at Saints, 10-11 at Rovers, 28-28 at Catalans he was unlucky.

I agree LC was an awful coach with the man management skills of a baboon.

It's quite simple really, it's Brian Smith. He gave us a taste of what it could be like and so now the mediocrity hurts so much more. As James say in sit down; "if I hadn't seem such riches I could live with being poor"

So there you go. Worst. Coach. Ever.

If the thread was "which coach did FC most damage" then Smith would win hands down, he nearly cost us the club we all love, and we ended up with Cleal in charge too!

I remember the game when casey ripped the players shirts off their backs in the changing room after the game. Can see agar doing the same kind of thing if we don't beat wire at home

what do you mean IF?

I honestly think some players have decided it doesn't matter what they do, Agar hasn't got the spine to drop them.