Please don't turn this into another slagathon. I'm just looking for those who still believe he is the man to tell me why. I can't for the life of me see why he is still in charge and just wondering if I'm missing some positives

No, not happy at all, and wasn't deluded when we were on our "winning run" either

the rest of SL are delighted!

Mr Whippy is.

Strangely my Hubby does not blame the coach for our situation he blames the players...The surprising thing is my hubby is an ex-player and has coached for several years, he believes if we get knocked out on Sunday and finish out the top 8 Agar will be sacked though and rightly so, he also believes whoever we bring in our problems will go on as they are much deeper! Mind you my hubby thinks although Fitz is a great defender he could not count on one hand how many lines he has broken since he joined FC so cannot understand the fuss people make when Fitz does not play...my hubby would probably get banned from this board

Was anyone ever happy with him as our coach?

At the beginning of the season when we were truly awful, some were still trying to be positive and hoping he'd turn it around, but I don't think anyone was 'happy' (maybe EX PRO?).

he's not alone, I really don't get the hype with Fitz.

was never happy with his appointment and gobsmacked he got given an extension, shown nothing in his 2 and a half years as a head coach to prove he has got what it takes, so NO from me

The BOD

He is cheap and he says 'yes'

Because the man is a machine, complete professional and a role model for any player playing the game.
He's not and never has been in the team to break tackles, he was recruited for his leadership, aggression and team/work ethic. For this he is beyond reproach imo. Although I do feel that its time for Tickle to take over (both his position and captaincy) who will give us more mobility ala Gallen.
The fact we are impotent in attack doesn't help either.

He'd probably make a decent scout but nothing much else . The board are as much to blame for appointing him in the first place .

its not just agar, i'm worried about the whole of the coaching set up - re. the other thread on the lack of young players being eased into the first team

No

OK, can you now justify those two comments?

You only have to look at the "Official Hull FC" facebook page to see that people are happy with Agar.

Still not match report on the official site either - just lots of stuff about Cardiff 2005 and a ticket story calling this weekend's game 'one of the most anticipated Carnegie Challenge cup fixtures in recent memory'. Wigan v Warrington anyone???

couldnt agree more..complete liability....and whoever gave horne a 2 year deal wants literally shooting in the face

...completely embarrassing descion....

It's there, just been buried further down. Not sure it's describing the game I saw though

Most definately not happy with him and i dont give a flying one what everyone says, id be happy with us to lose every game from now till the end of the season including finishing outside the top eight if it finally meant the board acted and removed him from his post

You'll struggle to find people who are happy with him. It's not just Agar though, the whole coaching set up needs changing and players should be more accountable at times too.

Would take the short trerm pain for long term gain.

Didnt agree with him getting job in 1st place and has proved to be totally out of his depth with Tactics and sub policy.....ruining players confidence and just all round inept......Our previous coaches was sacked for a damn sight less than what he is doing now.The winning run just paperd over the cracks imo.Someone stands near me and blames the players,yes they have to take some of the blame but Agar puts the team out with the plan...if plan A fails,he has not got a Plan B at all or plan c,d,e,f,g etc etc etc.Yet again on Fri he moved 2/3 players on 1 interchange...Houghton went off..Obst went to 9 and Washy to 6....aginst salford....Washy played 9 why do it in this match....AGAR= CLUELESS,INEPT,OUT OF HIS DEPTH.

Totally agree Paul...Agar,Webster,Last and co should all go...also agree to a extent about the players but when they go out with no game plan like friday,there will have been 1 but buggerd if i know where it was,what can you expect them to do

They have managed to score points and made line breaks all season, i'm pretty sure Agar didn't say stop doing this on Friday night. Yes Agar is very limited tactically but Friday was more about the players imo.

Fiday wouldn't have been so bad if it wasn't just teh latest in a long line of poor performances.

Anyway, as I thought, no one has a good word to say for him so I honestly can't understand why the board don't see the same