Bit of a defensive Nomad?

Imo, was resposible for the first 2 cas tries? (ish) First he dropped the bomb, then they scored, second, out of position)

I like him personally, but am a bit worried. He will be targetted and i think we could come unstuck?

First one was completely his fault. Second he had the thankless task of marking about 5 players so can't blame him for that one. He does worry me though, watch him when the opposition are attacking his side, he is just completely fixated on the ball, it's like he doesn't even realise there is another winger stood opposite him.

i have said this about sharp ever since i first saw him, reminds of a younger blacklock, ok with ball in hand but constantly wandering in defence

Good attacking player - but looks clueless in defence at times. We look very vulnerable down that wing, and teams know it.

Hall got shipped out for the same thing....clears lines well,enthuastic but awful in defence.

Hall got shipped out for the same thing....clears lines well,enthuastic but awful in defence.

Sharp is just another Craig Hall....sparky in offence but very poor in defence.

Well summed up.

I like the lad but I feel he is going to give us plenty of head-in-hands moments.

maybe whiting on the wing and turner in at centre worked well at times last season, i like sharp and when we signed him thought it was a good signing but really does worry me in defence

Knew he would get the blame somewhere.

Should have saved our money then.

I wonder if changing the backline to Sharp/Yeaman and Briscoe/Whiting would help balance things out a bit, but equally you could argue it creates two 'average' partnerships and removes the threat of Briscoe/Yeaman.

Craig Hall certainly had some shocking moments in a Hull shirts, but I don't remember him being half as bad as Sharp.

The lad is simply not super league material. All aspects of his game are poor imo, he cant even pass a ball for gods sake.

Totally out of his depth, needs a few weeks in the reserves.

So who plays on the wing?

Definitely not. You can't have the slowest player in our squad on the wing. Ridiculous

Nah id leave briscoe and yeaman on the left together as they look dangerous together. Like you say it will create two averages.

For me id drop Sharp,hes a liability every week and give Lynne a run for a few games....whats the worst that can happen?

Briscoe had a bad game last week and every one focused on it...sharps been consistantly bad IMO.

Lyne

Lyne who in the Wakefield game was stood in touch when he received a pass with no defenders near him?

You seriously think he's a better option than Sharp after watching the pair of them?

Can't see it in a million years.

At the moment yes...sharp should be dropped and i cant see what he offers that Lynne cant??

He was poor last night and hasn't settled in yet, but he'll score us trys.

Lynne isn;t anywhere near yet. He's not been up to it when he's started,

I would prefer neither of them, but Sharps performance last night was pathetic.

Lyne has a bit more oomph and passion, so on that I would give him the nod.

11 missed tackles this season from Sharp most of them led to tries, just not good enough.

Anyway, we should go all out to get Gleeson till end of season, there is room left on the cap

Just play with 12 men. There would be the same amount of space for the opposition to run into, but less chance of us knocking on