What the hell did the video ref see for robys try then that was never a try in a million years if they lose due to that i feel sorry for Crusaders.

Agreed, It's as if the referees have their own set of rules at times.

As Mcrae just mentioned if that had been anywhere else on the field it would of been deemed to of lost control.

Eddy and Stevo dont half p1ss we of there now trying to say it went back even if it did its a double movement.

clearly lost control. No try. Terrible decision by Smith

Costly win for Saints...a few injuries!!

Disgrace of a decision, obviously not going to be crucial in the context of the game now, but that is really not on! Blatant knock-on, the referees really make me scratch the old noggin at times!!

Two weeks running Nobby has been screwed by the officials

Eastmond, Puletua and Cunningham to join the list. It looks like they'll have to use even more (Quality) youngsters.

he was a yard short then knocked it on, feel sorry if they dont make play-offs

Unbelievable. Ian Smith should be embarrassed by that decision tonight. He clearly lost control of the ball therefore it can't be a try.

Even Eddie and Stevo expected a no try. What made me laugh even more was Phil Clark trying to defend the decision saying it might have touched the line before he lost it, no it didn't. It should never have been a try. It was clear as anything, he is looking at it in slow motion and still go it wrong.

Let hope it go OK for him in 2 weeks time

Thought it was a try at first glance but it wasn't, not sure what Smith was thinking.

That's what makes it more ridiculous IMO mate making that decision off the replay. It's not like he had to make a split second decision he had the benefit of watching it 3 or 4 times in slow motion. Pathetic.

What do you expect with this lot they all Pi-s in the same pot If he can give a try for a double movement he will give anything

your right never a try.
on to your second statement....now you how most of the other clubs felt over that contriversal penalty at the end of the game by danny tickle to lose the game for crusaders...

Yeah, but Lyne was taken out after he'd kicked....seen the footage?

Noble should have had ago at his own player for taking the player out he wouldn't have scored ..so why do it

Quote ="Locko's Luck"Eastmond, Puletua and Cunningham to join the list. It looks like they'll have to use even more (Quality) youngsters.'" news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/rugby_l ... 934411.stm I hope not as he's been a fantastic servant to the game. Awful way to end a glittering career.

Quote ="Locko's Luck"Eastmond, Puletua and Cunningham to join the list. It looks like they'll have to use even more (Quality) youngsters.'" news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/rugby_l ... 934411.stm I hope not as he's been a fantastic servant to the game. Awful way to end a glittering career.

He's not happy about the challenge as well, what a end to a great career

I was watching the game (admittedly on and off) and didn't see anything.

Seems like that was the way Ian Smith was as well

Quote ="Locko's Luck"news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/rugby_league/super_league/st_helens/8934411.stm I hope not as he's been a fantastic servant to the game. Awful way to end a glittering career.'" www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/sport/ ... 847008.ece Not always glittering. No smoke without fire

Quote ="Locko's Luck"news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/rugby_league/super_league/st_helens/8934411.stm I hope not as he's been a fantastic servant to the game. Awful way to end a glittering career.'" www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/sport/ ... 847008.ece Not always glittering. No smoke without fire