when is he due to go back to leeds or have we extended his loan deal until the end of season?

he is ooc at the end of the season aint he?i would not like to see him stay at hull beyond the end of this season think we should be blooding our own youngsters for the future.

You can have some players who aren't from Hull you know.

Aye, I think that's been a problem for us you know. Yes it's good to have Hull born players in our team, but if there not upto the required standard of SL then it's no good. As I've said before if they were that good, other teams would be chasing them. How many times do you hear players such as either of the Hornes, Kingy, Radders been linked to other teams? Hardly ever.

I for one would keep Broughton. Having Broughton,Briscoe and Hall as our cover players for injuries to the backs is okay for me.

If Agar stays I think it's nailed on he will sign for us. To me the performance of gibson showed the difference in class.

I just pray it's not at the expense of Hall.

Broughton rumoured to be signing for Wakefield.

that would not upset me

Yeah apparently going to Wakey and we're getting one of there young forwards. Pitts I think it is?

That was last seasons rumour.



He wants to stay at Leeds but they havent opened talks with him. Hull and Warrington are 2 named teams talking to him but there are a further 3 SL clubs who cant be named speaking to him too.

Would have Hall over Broughton personally.....they are on par in defence but Hall has that bit extra and would have read the play better when Yeaman got the ball out and he wasnt there.

Are you kidding......If the Rl suddenly ordered that each SL team could only have players born within 10 miles of the city/club they represent.......Hull FC & Hull KR would both be a major force in the game. We have some really talented players in this city......Allways have had. You only have to look at the amature game....The Hull clubs are allways doing well! As it stands now though.....We have to bring our young lads through the ranks with the risk of letting them go to teams that don't really have a youth development!
We would lose some good players....but so would everyone else. Plus if it was just for one season, for example....It would be interesting to see....Maybe a good 'scouting' exercise to root out some fresh talent! We'd still not have a scrum half though

GET A GRIP BEEN SPOT ON YOUNG ENGLISH AND A GREAT PROSPECT

Spot on.

would defo keep broughton if the salary cap allowed it.but would also depend on how much he wanted.

He could be the new Gareth Raynor, he plays alot like gareth and could be a great player in a few years. And who better to learn off then Raynor, Leeds obviously don't want to keep or they would have had him signed up by now.

I personally would sign him up.

I personally wouldn't sign him up. Don't think his defence is strong enough but if coached properly he may become a decent SL player.

Seems to be a liability in defence, also would be behind Calderwod, Raynor and Briscoe.