Now i understand this afternoon was a poor performance by all but Calderwood keeps persistantly dissapointing me, He seems to go down all too easy and seems more at home patting the ball back than trying to take it with both hands. I know we are all full of emotion at the minute but when Raynor gets back i really think he is going to struggle to get into the team on merit. But with our current system of picking players on name he will over Briscoe whom i think is the better winger at the minute. I know i'll get slated saying he has no quality ball but good wingers make there own oppertunities which i really dont think he does.

Thorman ..... Check

Agar ..... Check


Calderwood.... Check

HOUSE!!!!!

So where were all Briscoe's breaks then? I remember one...just trying to remember who put him through the gap...

Tommy Lee has been disappointingly good for some, I reckon.

Jesus, here we go again.

Calderwood is some way down the list of reasons for our current poor form. At least he looks to get involved.

It's seriously starting to annoy me now. When the ball was thrown back (can't remember who by) to nobody and we lost about 15 yards, the ball came out to Horne I think. He took it out wide to try and cart it up again and somebody behind me started slagging Calderwood off for being on his wing!

It's interesting that when Briscoe returns the ball, whether he breaks the tackle or not there's warm applause. With Hall and Calderwood on the other hand, people seem to immediately be looking for things to criticise no matter what they do.

Which winger was it that cost us a try by failing to deal with a kick into the in goal?

I'll give you a clue - it wasn't Calderwood.

It must be Calderwood's fault because....well, it just must be.

Is Balsawood meant to e offensive?
Because I had some numpty sat infront of me calling him it all the time!

there was a lad in front of me was going on about how crap colly was
he doesnt do much right BUT he doesnt do alot wrong
craig hall was poor for me again as is thorman

How much is Calderwood getting paid for "trying hard"? This is Super League, not under 10's.

well spotted it isnt under 10s why dont you tell us how much hes being paid as i couldnt tell you do you know what kr players are getting?

The point is, and I'll type this slowly for you, that Calderwood is no worse than several other members of the squad and actually better than a couple. And yet he gets these moronic threads about him after ever game.

To add to that, if a few of the others were 'trying' as hard as Calderwood we might not be in the state we currently find ourselves in.

East stand? In a abc caravans top? He was in front of me as well.

He is one of the team scapegoats!

Whenever the team did something bad, no matter what he did the people behind said it was his fault. Give him a break

Because idiots still expect him to be scoring tries for fun when they rightfully know that we are not a team who use our wingers. So how can he score tries!

The same old prop drives and a couple of scoots isnt funny anymore is it?

At no point did we change our TACTICS. I really feel for our outside backs because they will never see quality ball under the current set up.

Until we get the ball out wide quickly to the wingers and get them some quality ball, from some class centres hopefully, they will never score tries for fun, like Gardner does at Saints and the 2 wingers from Leeds, or any other wingers for that matter.

We play the most boring brand of rugby, even the commentators on radio knew how hull would play, and how salford were going to stop us, now if its that easy to stop hull, were doomed because commentators are telling everyone for free!

Both our centres all season have failed our wingers, people puzzle me by thinking graeme horne is playing well? He seems to be using calderwood as a scapegoat is my opinion, he never passes to him unless he's already messed up then he offloads a poor ball to calderwood, n who gets the blame, poor calderwood, now i know he's not done much since he got here but i believe most of that reason is that they just dont work together, mix things up a bit n see what happens?

Jesus fooking christ.........actually thought Calderwood was one of our better players today and didnt cost us a try like a certain other winger did.......getting to be a habit with this lad atm.

So why did we sign him then?

How can he score when turnstyle Horne doesnt give it him.

Oh FFS!