You still moaning about bullying? Thought you'd laid that to rest with your previous incarnation(s)


32 becomes 34, then. Oh dear..

Saints are in for Carney as well as Salford and a potential move back to the NRL. Can't see this one going far. Maybe more legs in the Sarginson rumour? www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/ ... ts-9968742

Saints are in for Carney as well as Salford and a potential move back to the NRL. Can't see this one going far. Maybe more legs in the Sarginson rumour? www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/ ... ts-9968742

Don't care how good he is. It would be stupid getting rid of a player with alleged poor professionalism and replacing them with....whatever you want to class Carney as.

here's my two penneth on it for what its worth.

£290,000ish for two player over which there have been big question marks concerning their integrity and off field behaviour is in itself good business and probabaly in the long term a bonus in the camp.

I think we will definitely miss Lineham but Westerman won't be missed at all, for all the reasons outlined above, he's had a pretty ineffective season and hadn't even started contract talks when he announced that he wanted away and that meant that it was very, very likely that he would be off anyway come 2017; with no recompense for us at all.

Leeds saw the light and refused to pay up but Warrington were more naive and to get £150,000 for Joe is without doubt the 'killing' of the season so far and great business for the Club, but for the fans the acid test of Pearson's situation and ambition is what he does next.

Will those two come back to bite us? For me Lineham definitely will he'll score a few in the corner and no mistake but I doubt very much Westerman will. If we bring a top quality outside back in then for me we will be in a better position, balance wise, than we were before Westy went! No new signing and we are a side selling to survive, which sometimes has to happen, but invariably points to a team in decline. However with what is coming in already next year using Westermans cap space to bring a strike winger in would I think show a team jettisoning the problem areas and addressing the weaknesses. I think a lot of fans will be watching Adams next move very closely as Motu Tony said this morning, we now have a bit of cap space available but what will we do with it.....if anything?

Good deal .. If we can use the £ to bring in a quality back , Preferably a centre .

Wink or no, you realise how daft that statement is given FC Live, yes?

I've seen every game Westerman has played for this club.

Good job I'm not arrogant enough to use the Royal We when referring to my own opinions, eh?

Quote ="Mrs Barista"Saints are in for Carney as well as Salford and a potential move back to the NRL. Can't see this one going far. Maybe more legs in the Sarginson rumour? www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/ ... ts-9968742'" That report is from sept1 lots gone on since then. Why would Wigan want to release Sarginson? no sense in that

Quote ="Mrs Barista"Saints are in for Carney as well as Salford and a potential move back to the NRL. Can't see this one going far. Maybe more legs in the Sarginson rumour? www.manchestereveningnews.co.uk/ ... ts-9968742'" That report is from sept1 lots gone on since then. Why would Wigan want to release Sarginson? no sense in that

Wrong.

Sorry just though I'd copy your response when arguing a point.

We're sharing rumours. I think I read Sarginson is OOC, maybe they want to promote internally? On Carney he's linked with several clubs, NRL, union and staying put.

If we are seriously looking at an outside back from Wigan its more likely to be Josh Charnley

Actually you are wrong as after a bit of research I found that Hull FC LIVE started in 2012, so unless you saw every game that he played in 2011, you haven't seen all the games he hasn't played.

Anyway Carney*for Westerman looks good business to me.

Shaul
Carney
Logan
Fonua
Naughton/Talanoa/Lancaster

Looks much better than I thought.




*If true

Carney's a definite no.

Player vote I believe

Yep, club also spoke to Thompson as well, who had a veto but it wasn't needed.

would like to see ben jones bishop come in but seems very injury prone though

Probably the right decision, excellent player, but we don't need the changing room disrupted.

Wonder how they voted, as they aren't back in training yet and some not even in the country?

Just been digging. Apparently Radders on hols hence delay. Carney has agreed to the terms. Players aren't keen but Radders was gonna discus it?
So I don't know if it's on or off ha. Sod it I'm off to bed

Well Dave, there's these wonderful things called mobile phones.......

Reckon it was less of a man for man vote and more a quick text/call to a certain some.

Plus they only actually get 2 weeks away from official club duties.

Not convinced this kind if thing would be done by text/phone.

I wonder if Micheals, Naughton, Lancaster and Talanoa voted?

Good summary

Smoke and mirrors obviously.

Feka rang me and asked for my vote.

No brainer business for Hull. Just hope that we bring a back in with real strike.