Tickle has been a complete liability since his injury. Mistakes are the only time you notice him.

Terrific. Down 2 points after another penalty.

He was actually playing a little better but that offload was stupid.

Well recovered by Crookes to force the drop out. And Catalan should be penalised for slowing the drop out down as well.

Been quite a good game in testing conditions.

Not sure I would be kicking this. Catalans are starting to look tired and this leaves us clearing our line again.

Amazingly few mistakes compared to recent games in similar conditions.

That's disgusting. Clear obstruction in back play and they haven't even looked.

Poor option to kick, but Horne pushed in back play and Webb takes him out over the line.

That's not what the ref asked for!!

Absolutely brilliant play from Shaul. Fantastic try.

Jamie Shaul take a bow.

Breath taking

brilliant from Shaul to not get tackled and to get up and accelerate like that!

That's the winning try according to Radio Humber.


Classic.

FC looking the better side at the moment in a close game. Could still go either way, this.

Fantastic effort from Shaul .

Typical hull performance, great in defence awful in attack.

Once again one our outstanding young backs might save us.

Best thing to come out this season is the stepping up of our young players.

At this point I'm pretty glad we didn't drop Shaul.

Miller looked a bit better so far, put a clever kick in and even took the line on a few times as opposed to crabbing along and getting caught.

I don't think we're that bad imo . Not the sort of conditions to be "throwing it about " .

I'd agree with that. In fact with a little more luck we might have had at least one more try. Definite improvement over recent games.

Keep the updates coming, gotta go to work!

Need better line speed in defence. Letting them make too many yards.

Bloody hell Crookes, you flaming idiot!

Need another Catalan mistake.