so a top 4 side nearly had its ar5e whupped by a bottom 4 side today and only got away with it by the skin of your teeth with a full team and such an outstanding coach and an extra man on the pitch....PURE QUALITY

That does happen a lot at Craven Park doesn't it?

Was there FORWARRRRRRRRRDDDDDDDDD shouts for every Hull pass?

As I've said earlier, Fox slipped off the tackle before Tansey passed it. If he had stood up and carried on he would have been allowed to. Or say he was tackled from behind, Tanseys arms hit the floor but Fox rolled over him and lost contact. That isn't tackle made either.
When the pass was made Fox wasn't holding him and the try should have stood.

Did you not watch the game?

we nearly did..if the incompetant ref hadn`t called for a forward pass....sumtimes just sumtimes the refs are to blame you know...as they are human and do make mistakes,its not always the players contrary to popular belief.

We'll never know because BENT-ham couldn't be bothered to look at the best angle before making a decision. Why have video refs if they aren't going to look at the best view to make a decision. Whatever happened to benefit of the doubt or does that only come into play when it's Leeds, Wigan and St's?

In my experience, the vast majority of supporters are clueless. I've also never failed to be amazed at the number of players who have little concept of 'The Laws of the Game'.

Mind you, I can only speak from practical experience, rather than becoming a Sky armchair expert

Hmmmmm whupped? The score was 24-18 to rovers to make it 2-0 this year. We took advantage of a side who's attacking prowess would not look out of place in national league two. We led through out the game and come away with a win. But somehow you think you can justify saying we "nearly had our whupped" the key word in there is nearly. We come away with two points.


And as for the outstanding coach we are in the top four a manager will not be judged on a game but upon league position and you are a seriously fading club with quite possibly the most clueless manager in the league.

What the point in having a video ref IF he does not look at all angles before he post NO TRY .

Dunno, ask Steve Cross, after he chalked off 3 Widnes tries at a Widnes v Hull FC game, back in 2003 or thereabouts

This supporter as refereed at Academy level so as a perfect concept of the rules of the game thanks, mind you it's not exactly needed to judge a forward pass. All you need to do is have a pair of eyes.

screwed/robbed either way silverwood got it wrong! never a forward pass. saying that, fisher should never have been allowed to make that run.

playoffs look out of reach now, so lets hope we play like this for the rest of the season, give us something to be entertained

as for rovers, good luck in the play offs, if cooke or dobson get an injury they are f00ked, as for newton, man of steel???

Get your red and white glasses off we owned you for most of the game!!

So, being in the right place, at the right time, has nothing to do with it then?

Or were you one of those who always was there?

Why aren't you refereeing at Academy level any longer?

Get over it. I resigned from 2nd grade (the old 'A' team) level because of work commitments. I was however big enough to realise that I wasn't doing the job any justice. It was only after I'd resigned my place that I found out that I'd have been promoted to Grade 1.

Your excuse is what?

You owned us? oooooohhhh you mean you had most of the posession but once again showed how clueless you are with ball in hand, a few offloads in the tackle and it drew in your clueless fans and made them beleive they was playing good rugby.























What a joke.

yet we made a top 4 team look quite ordinary!!

you been home to change your underwear yet???

It wasn't actually. The momentum of the player hadn't stopped. Simply having your hand on a player as he rolls forward on the floor doesn't complete the tackle if it isn't controlled. The fact that Fox felt like he had to have a 'second bite' showed that he didn't think it was complete either. Two poor poor decisions.

Because I couldn't be a voiceless puppet, I have this thing called an opinion which referees aren't allowed to have if it means going against another official. Also been on the line at A-team games and told by the grade one refs, I'm grade 1 I'll ref this you just tell me if the ball goes into touch or over the posts.

Good enough rugby to make the top 4 team sweat a bit on their own patch!!

a bit of a shock that thought you was going to be a top four team this year, or at least you should be, so it's not really a surprise that you nearly matched us seen as you should be up here if it wasn't for your heartless players.


And im home but i still have sperm in my trousers from watching Paul Cooke play rugby it is an extraordinary sight.

Close but NO cigar sunshine, have a nice off season

Wonder if you'll enjoy it as much next season?

don't wear out that laminator with your cookie photos



he did 4 or 5 things tonight not much else, but it was the most important 4 or 5

will give it a couple of weeks until you're all bagging him again!!

Not another one who thinks Cookie wont be at Rovers, he is ours not yours, get over it and move along




Who do you have him down to go to?

Wakey, Hudds or, s s, You?

Take it your still under the same illusion about the GF as you where about the CC, look where that got you!