But not work, surely? Otherwise, we'd just employ Crocker to a French office or something and have him over here.

We should think why he was released in the first place, but he could be the player to make us tick again.

Is this a stopgap for this season only? If so, would take Robinson. If either are going to be 1st choice for yesra to come, I'd rather have a top class player then a pretender!

brough wont be coming back

Thank god!

why?
i would love him back,

How do you know he isn't?....

Technically he is our cast off!

he has just moved to wakefield,
dont want to dig into it too much,

Being allowed to work in France does not allow him to work here. At leaset for a period of time. I believe that the 2 biggest loopholes for this rule are Greece and Belgium, whereby after 2 years you get a passport, hence an EU passport will allow you to work in the uk

Remember when we got rid and almost all the people on here thought it was a wise decision, months later a few people suggested it was the wrong decision to get rid and they got shot down by the majority. He's maybe not the world beater most want but we'd have done a whole lot better for the past two seasons had we kept him!

Indeed, I cannot even remember what my opinion was on it at the time. To be honest, dont think I was that bothered. Agreed though, in hindsight we should have kept him

Jamie Thackray and to another extent Shaun Briscoe ??

yes hutchie,
but at the time i knew they was both wrong decisons,
who's the other sh

Maybe, maybe not. Brough is a far better player now than he was when he left, and who's to say that progression would have happened if he'd stayed at Hull? We hardly have a stellar record in developing halfbacks after all.

I totally disagree with this, I've not seen one aspect of his game improve. Same with Briscoe, they just look better at the clubs they're at now because we've hit such a decline.

greenshield is a good attacking player, but defensively he isnt in the class of briscoe etc...would defo be worth a punt tho

tony or briscoe
thorman or brough

point proved.

why do we need another fullback when we have cover there. I would stick with horney there and look for either another stand off or a scrum half.

Really ?

If anyone thinks Brough is worth £100k they need their head read!

yes really, hence why the dragons ( st george) got rid sharpish afew years back...he may have improved but what you see is what you get with clint.....he's in the same mould as motu tony...attcking = class....defence = average...and that is mainly high-ball senarios which are his downfall...

Briscoe and Brough.

Sorted

there we go

Tony and Brough.