Go on then - how many great games has Lauaki had in his time here?

In my opinion he is a class act and one that will get better by the week, he is explosive and unpredictable and a long term part of the plan, also in my opinion he has had quite a few decent games and Hudds probably being his best to date however he has again in my opinion been under used and played out of position ..
a quality player nevertheless

We can't wish away Phelps yet, what's to say he has a blinder of a season and deserves an extension?

Another thing I don't get is this notion of 'pay per play' players, does this actually ever happen? If it does it must be very rare.

I think/hope Phelps will go well, he is solid, and he will no doubt be playing for a contract it may take him a few games to get match fit and settle though which is understandable.

I made that up in respect of Moa - he'll be on a tiny contract if he gets paid per minute on the field

Wasn't just aimed at you, Chris, just in general it is said on here a lot but I'm sure it doesn't really exist!

I think Moa will be one of our first extensions to be made this season.

He may indeed, as may Horne and Fitz.

Then we may only have room for a halfback.

Might be able to afford a good one with Long, Lauaki/moa, dowes and washys wage!

Can see Fitz, Long and Dowes leaving out of those players.

Then we'd need a prop for fitz and a half for long.

I'd only keep one of lauaki and moa though.

No brainer for me ..Moa, although I really like Hame I think there is more to come from Moa.

Yep, another good prop and quality half next season must be priority.

Undecided to Lauaki/Moa, both going really well. If I had to choose, it would be Moa, however I'm impressed with Hame's start to the season.

The decision maybe made for us if they get another offer, if that happened I'd look for another big islander prop if no uk props were available.

Indeed. Would be inclined to do the same, too. Hope Sam stays on though.

personally i hope long,fitz and dowesy go, longy to old now injury prone and we need a top fit scrum half, fitzy been brilliant but as a quota player and due to his age and niggling injuries i feel we should move on and replace him were we need to strenghen and dowesy just isnt good enough. im undeceided on moa and laukai potentially both could be really good and are still young but both are quota players and could we get better? , moa starting to progress really well still areas of his game he needs to improve and needs more game time, lauaki potentially could be a top player for us but dosent get used right and dosent get enough game time again. washy is decent no world beater but will always do a job with his versitility i would offer him a reduced contract as backup and the same for horney aswell unless he can prove this year that he can play a full year injury free and look back to his best which at this moment dosent look likely but you never know. cameron phelps well we will just have to wait and see how well he does for us before making judgement but again if we are ambitious as a club then a top fullback will be signed

Fitzy could go on for a couple more years if rotated in the props.

Moa will leave as I expect a lot of top SL clubs will be interested, although he would be the first player I'd try and sign to a long term deal I just don't see why he'd want to stay, I'd probabally keep Hame if he kicks on a bit, encouraging start to the season from him.

No chance. He's not happy at Hull

Really? have you spoken to him

Yeah, chatting to him at the meet the player thing the other week

And he actually said ''i aint happy here''

Agar is messing Moa about I mean 14 minutes against the giants!!!!!

Is a bit strange, hope it gets sorted out very soon, would be a big loss if Moa goes imo.

No, but he did say he didn't know if he'd be at Hull beyond this season and his demeanour indicated that he wasn't that happy with things.

If he's hardly getting any game time under Agar , He wont be a that big of a loss.

No Argument here with that selection.