has everyone gone mad, the whole point, of playing rugby league is to win first and foremost, so why do we field crap players,,, second of all i know the history of the johns family, i was making refrence to the fact we have 2 crap halfs, and andrew johns with no eyes could play better than any of ours....thanks

Andrew Johns has just turned 35 and retired through injury two years ago.

Oh and Motu isn't a liability.

Mal Meninga anyone??

Is he here all week

first of all i herd it was both the johns brothers, if not then the dentist needs to alter his diary,,,,,

secondly i would never wish an injury upon any player, and were i dont think thorman deserves to be in the hull fc squad, they could be slim pickings, for those at the craven park tip, after the dobo has been prized away,,,

I'll happily pay for it to happen, something to smile about at least!

johnsy maybe 35 but thorman looked 60 last nite, motu looked like he needs some vallies.....

Why is Motu being bagged?

Wasn't it his first game back from a pretty serious injury?

or the alternative non-abusive arguement would be that people can change their minds and through desperation some are seeing Berro as a better choice than Thorman. (but not the ideal choice as he aint a 7)

Thanks for your contribution though!!

, Just looked out of place and very nervous last nite.. imo..

He is not mate, it's just Dazcool, but he also wants us to sign the Johns brothers so i'd move on

You never saw Dave Brown then.

I know Thorman has been crap but you dont need to put his face in it.

If Motu needs to go then we really are up s**t creek without a paddle. I'd like to try Houghton at scrum half. I think his quick running from dummy half would work really well from the base of the scrum as there's more room to work in. Let's face it, you could perm one from at least four in that position and it would be an improvement, defensively, creatively and not to forget kickingwise.

Reg Reagan would be a much better signing

Apparently Johnny Whiteley might be up for a game.

regarding Thorman i don't know if it has already been mentioned but

the amount of people on here that were saying:

'thats a good signing ' / 'perfect player alongside Horne' etc

at the start of the season and after the first few games has got to be at least 80% - Now we can all see how much of a poor player he is and hopefully Agar has realised the error of his ways

Hinesight is a great thing when people are saying we should't have signed hi

I'd like to ask him if he's embarrassed about picking up his fat pay cheque every month for doing feck all while the people who pay his wages go without so they can follow the club they love

I said he was shiite. I also said rule and agar weren't up to it.

Sometimes I hate being right all of the time

I think Richard Whiteley would be a shoe in for scrum half at the moment

I'm not sure you are right all the time. I'll have to ask your missus.

To be honest we might as well stick a shirt on a scarecrow and plant it in the pitch. Would certainly give us better defence and more attacking/kicking options than the current number 7!

Johnny Whiteley might be up for Chairman .

She'd say I'm always wrong but she's always wrong proving I'm always right

like it never a truer word spoken