Not bashing Hall, but he hasn't really improved in nearly 4 years. Maybe needs a good run at left centre, but we all know that's not going to happen.

Quite right.

You're right to a point....but don't forget the fact he came back and played well for us at the tail end of last season, when played in his correct position

Will defend him on that one...it was right in front of us and Washy threw the ball like he was 20 yards away...no wonder it was hot to handle

Made no more mistakes tonight than one or two others, but was a little less effective in attack than usual. Kicked the goals well, including the one from the touchline that gave us a crucial buffer.

No...looked very good when he came back to us after being there...plus i will take the word of a Widnes player at the time who was with Hall and said he is a superb player who needs the right coaching.

knew as soon as I logged on Hally would be the scapegoat AGAIN,

Take his word, but he hasn't looked too clever all season.

Personally I thought that Hall had his best defensive game for us tonight, I know thats not hard against the Wakey side that faced us tonight but his definently put the effort in.

We won, did you know?

A little unfair to start a thread criticising Hall tonight, not the worst offender by any stretch of the imagination.

Agreed, getting very worried about how quickly Lauaki switches off!

I will seeing as he knows what he is on about....he isnt being coached right,,,gets dropped when wonder-boy is just as bad....get the right coach and watch him go....Yeaman was the same but he had Barnett to learn off...Hall has a coach who likes to bully him and no class centre to learn off

Did okay tonight, was an average performance, some solid hits in defence but his attack wasn't its usual self. Good kicking aswell, don't think they was any need to kick them as high as he did though

Do you really believe that crap? He gets dropped for Yeaman or Whiting, fair do's IMO.

Bolloxs.........He wasnt the worst at Wigan/...played out of position and is dropped.........why doest Agar drop Briscoe who is just as bad defensively??????

I don't have the answer to that and i agree with you regards Briscoe. I just don't buy the "bullying" "scapegoat" rubbish.

Hall's constant looking for the intercept nearly cost us on several occasions. He's a liability in defence. I am alone in thinking that I'd prefer Whiting's common sense and all round game in the centre with Hall's pace out on the wing?

Have you ever seen a real centre play?

I don't mean a frustrated 2nd rower like Yeaman or Senior, I mean a real centre. Someone who has a turn of speed, is swift of foot, can come off either foot and is always looking to put either his winger away or turn the ball back infield.

what do you expect a centre to do?

I'm with baldy on this, Hall has gradually had his skills coached out of him

i have coddy, last one i saw like that was called jimmy leulaui

Name me 5 such players in SL now. The games moved on. Deal with it.

Funny how people forget them little points scored is crucial in a game played like tonites was,,if you doubters can do do any better please do

Sweet; I'll ring Agar tomorrow and get myself put intot he team to shore up that side of the defence!

you do that that but i dont think they need 4 foot circus piggy me midgets,,who knows feck all about nothing,and you can quote me on that!!

Always defended Hall, but he looked shocking tonight. Lets hope it ain't permanent