Having seen them draw once and lose 5 times at Wembley but seen 2 wins in 3 successive Grand Finals, guess which one I would prefer?

Challenge Cup at Wembley for me.

I think the GF is harder to win & more prestigious, and I imagine fans of most other clubs would say the GF too, but due to our history of cup finals going back decades, that's the one I'd be happier to win at this moment in time. Once that's out of the way, GF every time.

Challenge Cup for me for complete personal reasons as the night of the grand final I'm flying home from the Caribbean so I will not be able go or even watch it live.

The joys of years of hurt as an FC supporter didn't even consider when grand final was when I booked the holiday a year ago.

Not sure I catch your drift with your GF comment?

1956-58 we reached three successive Grand Finals, winning two of them.

In the 50's and early 60's we had 3 Yorkshire Cup Finals, followed by 3 Championship Finals (now called Grand Finals), followed by 2 Wembley Finals. That was some team we had then. Lets hope our present squad can do something similar. I was present at all those finals and would love to experience it again. Its been a long time since Cardiff.

Just been having a gander at our Championship wins/runners up etc:

1919-20 - Winners by GF
1920-21 - Winners by GF
1935-36 - Winners by GF
1955-56 - Winners by GF
1956-57 - Runners up in GF
1957-58 - Winners by GF
1982-83 - Winners by coming 1st
2006 - Runners up in GF

Challenge Cup

:
1907-08 - Runners up
1908-09 - Runners up
1909-10 - Drew, lost the replay
1913-14 - Winners
1921-22 - Runners up
1922-23 - Runners up
1958-59 - Runners up (Wembley)
1959-60 - Runners up (Wembley)
1979-80 - Runners up (Wembley)
1981-82 - Drew at Wembley, won the replay
1982-83 - Runners up (Wembley)
1984-85 - Runners up (Wembley)
2005 - Winners
2008 - Runners up (Wembley)
2013 - Runners up (Wembley)

finishing top means you are the best team in the league,gf is just a gimmick to appease sky.as for Wembley,its not where u win it,its if you win it and how many times u win it that counts.

Grand Final for me.
Would love us to be known as 'The Champions' next year instead of one of the usual suspects. Plus the chance of been named 'World Champions' by playing the best team in the NRL would be incredible.

CC at Wembley would be nice just to shut that mob up once and for all.

Otherwise league, although we're doing the double anyway.

It's hardly a gimmick to appease Sky. Winning the Championship via grand Final is actually our more traditional method of declaring Champions.

Out of 109 League Champions, 70 have been decided by Grand Final.

When a lot of people started watching in the late 70's/80's it was decided by who finished top, which I imagine is why many people se the GF as a gimmick or not traditional.

Either. Would just be nice to win something but if I had to choose I would go league. More kudos with that nowadays, but it's a close decision. I don't really rate the lls as a major honour, and the job isn't finished then either

Would still be happy to win the league leaders shield though, as long as we won something else as well

Challenge Cup,

We need that Wembley monkey off our back, first and foremost.

As a Wire fan, i found the romance of Wembley much more special than the Grand Final. It probably helps the memory that we won it. There was much more excitement around the Challenge Cup, again maybe due to the time we last won something. I also think winning the Challenge Cup drains you. You can see generally after the Challenge Cup the winners tend to tail off and Leeds nearly did last season. Whether its complacency or something else? Having said that the Challenge Cup is a better day, i want us to win the GF as i want us to play in the World Club Challenge. Taking on the best in the world!

Challenge Cup win for me. I've waited thirty six years so far for a Wembley win and that's long enough. A Wembley win would be massive for the club. Knowing us once we win there we'd go back and win it the following year too.

Wembley for me,

Lose in the semis of the CC but with a GF win would do for me, losing the CC final again would be soul destroying hence I'd rather lose in the semis if that was pre-ordained. Being greedy I'd definitely have the treble mind, then we really would look like the cat that got the cream, a small tweety burd and a place in front of the fire

Fair play.

grand final every time seen us pick up the CC twice, wembley thing is nothing to me think it means more to the dobbins

Strange man

I think it's because you have such a long build up to Wembley that it feels more exciting. You have the best part of a month of anticipation, playing games in between and praying you don't pick up any injuries. Fans tend to make more of a weekend of it as well, especially with it being the bank holiday weekend.

CC at Wembley if it was one or the other.

To be honest after all the years of seeing seasons come and go and no silverware I'll be over the moon with anything CC or GF don't care though both would do nicely hahaha not that I am being greedy.

i`m 77yrs old this year,and would love to see us win the cup at wembley.