No difference to me.

Yet you've posted several times about it.

Great shot. Strong, but fair.

Great hit, easily our hardest tackler. Had his best game for us tonight.

looked a fair hit to me, I was more disappointed bentham never took any action after o'meley scored, was it grix who came in with a cheapshot after?

typical hudds though, can dish out the hard tackles but cry foul when its returned!

Very much so. Pretty pathetic on a couple of occasions leaving the ball behind after being brought back for a scrum as well. Bit cheap really - don't think they'll be challenging Wigan or Wire despite their league position on that showing - not really any better than us.

I was close to where it happened on the west side.

Robinson took the line on, dummied, delayed and finally turned in toward the on coming Ellis, who cleaned Robinson out fairly. Ellis' arms were around Robinson, so the contact with the head was purely accidental. It was a fair attempt at a legal tackle.

And it would be a non post if you lost

Quote ="Mild mannered Janitor"I was close to where it happened on the west side. Robinson took the line on, dummied, delayed and finally turned in toward the on coming Ellis, who cleaned Robinson out fairly. Ellis' arms were around Robinson, so the contact with the head was purely accidental. It was a fair attempt at a legal tackle.'" You sure it was "fairly" instagram.com/p/be4KP5tIPQ/ According to the refs forum last week any contact with the head whether deliberate or not is a penalty. Can definitely see contact to the head. So there was no fairly about it. 6 points which should have been a penalty.

Quote ="Mild mannered Janitor"I was close to where it happened on the west side. Robinson took the line on, dummied, delayed and finally turned in toward the on coming Ellis, who cleaned Robinson out fairly. Ellis' arms were around Robinson, so the contact with the head was purely accidental. It was a fair attempt at a legal tackle.'" You sure it was "fairly" instagram.com/p/be4KP5tIPQ/ According to the refs forum last week any contact with the head whether deliberate or not is a penalty. Can definitely see contact to the head. So there was no fairly about it. 6 points which should have been a penalty.

Quote ="jools"You sure it was "fairly" instagram.com/p/be4KP5tIPQ/ According to the refs forum last week any contact with the head whether deliberate or not is a penalty. Can definitely see contact to the head. So there was no fairly about it. 6 points which should have been a penalty.'" I cannot see anything wrong. Robinson is small end of. Ellis is hitting him straight on.

Quote ="jools"You sure it was "fairly" instagram.com/p/be4KP5tIPQ/ According to the refs forum last week any contact with the head whether deliberate or not is a penalty. Can definitely see contact to the head. So there was no fairly about it. 6 points which should have been a penalty.'" I cannot see anything wrong. Robinson is small end of. Ellis is hitting him straight on.

Catalans look like they'll have more problems with bans after watching the highlights last night, couple of very bad shoulder charges

Good, we need all the help we can get

So because robbos small there's nothing wrong! He can't change his height but Ellis can alter his approach . Contact with the head is a penalty regardless of the players size or intent! Ellis should bend his back - which reading your forum sounds like is the problem with your team all round. Not much effort by the fans yesterday either- 10,500 mute hull fans- must be something in the water.
He will get a caution no more, which is right but to say you can't see anything wrong with that tackle suggests you are either lying to defend Ellis or are clueless about the rules.

The ref saw nothing wrong.
The video appears to show nothing wrong.
You suspect he won't be penalised for it.

Are you a bit slow?

On the Hudds forum you complained about Hull's 'spoiling tactics' but didn't mention your own side's slowing of the ptb. I'd suggest it's your knowledge of the [ilaws[/i of the game that is flawed.

Interesting, a Huddersfield fan commenting about another teams fans!! You say not much effort but at least there were 10,500 there unlike at Fart-town/Goat-Farm or whatever you're choosing to call it this week.

In fairness Hudds seemed to bring the vast majority of their home support yesterday which is no mean feat.

A grand total of 200-300? Wow. A side 2nd in table deserves 2000-3000 away support.

Ellis attempted to make a legitimate tackle on Robbo.. End of the day he was running across the line and ended up getting hit.

If hudds fans want to complain, how about we talk about Crabtrees hit on Miller???

Having seen the incident on Sky last night, I think it looked worse than it was. However, Eddie and his mates replayed the hit over and over again looking for something to criticise. RFL will look at it because of the attention it has received but should only caution at the most.

Quote ="jools"You sure it was "fairly" instagram.com/p/be4KP5tIPQ/ According to the refs forum last week [uany contact with the head whether deliberate or not is a penalty[/u. Can definitely see contact to the head. So there was no fairly about it. 6 points which should have been a penalty.'" That should be interesting one to police.

Quote ="jools"You sure it was "fairly" instagram.com/p/be4KP5tIPQ/ According to the refs forum last week [uany contact with the head whether deliberate or not is a penalty[/u. Can definitely see contact to the head. So there was no fairly about it. 6 points which should have been a penalty.'" That should be interesting one to police.

I think the proof is here. No shoulder charge, Robinson's poor little bonce clashed with Ellis' chest.

Robinson's knees bent as well before the tackle so I doubt his head was 5ft above the ground on impact. Ellis' left arm on the player so no shoulder charge whatsoever. Maybe we can get Rich Agar to demand an apology off Anderson. That said the league will probably give Ellis 3 matches and warn Crabtree for his tackle technique.

how is contact difficult to police? surely its easier to police than whether or not its deliberate! - its either contact or not contact with the head - the stills kindly shown by the hull fan above clearly show contact with the head so its a penalty.
any contact with the head is a penalty -That was the explanation given by the ref when mullaly was penalised for tackling gardner after he fell over into the tackle.