We are now if we haven't been for a while a selling club brought carvell ,willi manu Jordan turner andy lynch tom briscoe,ben crooks,herimia now tom lineham leading try scorer!

And we replaced them with ben galea joe arundel Jason crooks Stuart howarth Shannon McDonnell Gareth Ellis liam coburn

If rumour right washbrook back????
If you buy worse players than you let go then downward spiral welcome to battling for survival bottom 4

Whose next to pastures new when we don't play him like lineham shaul???
Play Rankin at hooker or bring in farges from Salford who wants away

Fages wanted out, Marwan says if a club comes up with £700k you can go, we let a dream team player, top scorer with 2 years left on his deal go for a pittance.

Anyone checked on AP yet?

I remember when I was reading Shakespeare at school and at first thinking I just read a load of words that don't belong in the same sentence, but apparently they did, maybe this will make sense a couple of years down the line

Back on topic.

I think a lot will depend on who we've signed Stocky. And to be fair, whilst you're not a fan, Ellis has hit top form this season. I think Lineham like Crooks before him probably had a bit too much success a bit too soon and we're failed as a club to reach our own expectations. As well as money, players want to win things. That's a little more likely at clubs like Warrington at the minute. We've also spent a few quid on transfer fees ourselves. I'll reserve my judgement on next years squad until it's finalised.

Selling Lineham does not make us a selling club.

Selling any other players as well this season would.

sorry, but anybody who dosnt think gareth ellis has been awesome this season and is turning out to be a great signing, dosnt have know anything about rugby league!!?

It's easy to list the less successful signings like you have, but what about the signings than have been successful like Paea, Feka, Pryce, Sneyd, Thomspon etc.

Dissapointing to see him go but every team in SL sell or let players go. It happens but of course theres a massive over reaction to it. Let'swait and see who we have got

Mark Minichiello.

Seriously poor opening post.

You mention paea but he's off too he is not playing Thomson and I am thrilled g Ellis is playing well for hull fc its been s two year wait ! And the few minutes he has played in recent seasons hes overdue a good run feka too has not been given enough games this season in my opinion, I was dissapointed to lose sam moa too ,mini best buy in recent times

You don't think Ellis has played well for us for 2 years?

Was McDonnell that bad a signing for you, thought he was playing well until his injury. He was claimed as a bad signing because Shaul was seen as the shining light and SM was blocking him. Now Shaul is playing second fiddle to Rankin who the fans seem to want to keep.

Apart from lineham who was the last player we sold?

How long before lineham with good service from his centre instead of a greedy past his best cart horse with good coaching becomes an international ? Haven't we given the fumbling dustman a long deal too?! And we should use the money to secure a decent hooker Houghton tackles but his passing and creativity is not good enough

You could also ask - "how long till Naughton or Lancaster have a walk in of a try as Lineham pushed in too close to Chris Bridge when we are attacking there line"

Was a good signing and a bit unlucky, I didn't actually agree with his list, for a start it had Ellis on it, that wasn't my point.

We have missed herimia the most

But Adam Pearson stated publically (Sporting headlines HDM on 2/10/2013) that 'There is absoloutley no chance of Tom Lineham or any of our young talent leaving this club. Lineham, Shaul, Crooks, these kids are our future and it doesn't matter what club wants them, there is no chance any will go. It will happen over my dead body.
Two out of three gone and Shaul rumoured by some fans to be on his way, I think most will appreciate why AP didn't want to comment on the matter whn asked by the local press.

Exactly. Its so long ago no-one can remember.

There is a world of difference between selling players (Lineham) and players who want to leave at the end of their contract despite the club offering them a new deal e.g. Briscoe, Manu, Paea.

The latter scenario is how many players move clubs.

However as I said in my earlier post I would be worried if we were to sell anyone else this season.

That was two years ago, are you saying that Tom should stay at Hull for the rest of his life?

Still a bit of naive statement (he has done a few) from AP.

Isn't it funny how some on here jump on any news which is not so good but keep stum on any good news. Just saying

Funny haha?

Wish people would bloody stop going on about Heremaia - He was average at best and had one good game in four if he was lucky. Plus he told the club he was retiring so the club made other plans then Widnes waved a wad under his nose so he took it - hardly the clubs fault

Maybe a bit over the top, but got a good point, he was overrated by a lot of fans IMO, was getting a few little injuries and would have been on good money for a player who only plays 40 minutes. Houghton has outplayed him twice already this year.

Heremaia Did he play last week? yes he did and did nothing some on here are either dobbins or complete idiots.Selling club? until lineham I cannot remember the last players we sold. Paea along with Moa wants to be back in Oz nothing the club can do about that.Briscoe wanted out nothing the club could do about that.Crooks regardless what some think lost the plot and still has not found it,he thought he was better than he was.I would rather Lineham stayed but he wants out then gat something for him for me its a no brainer ,many on hereare not happy we have started to show real promise and feel the need to latch on to anything negative.Good luck to the lad..we move on