www.hullfc.com/hullfc/contents/?p=2737 Quote Hull FC will hold a minute’s noise for the late Arthur Keegan before the opening engage Super League clash with Wigan Warriors at the KC Stadium on Friday (8pm).'"

www.hullfc.com/hullfc/contents/?p=2737 Quote Hull FC will hold a minute’s noise for the late Arthur Keegan before the opening engage Super League clash with Wigan Warriors at the KC Stadium on Friday (8pm).'"

Good decision and very well deserved by Arthur

This will be followd by the usual 79 minutes silence at the KC

Fitting tribute to a Hull FC legend

not a fan of a minutes noise as i always feel it was brought in because of mindless idiots who couldn;t keep quiet.
However we will go along with it.

I agree, silence is more respectful imho, but we are marking Arthur Keegan's passing, which is the main thing.

In these cases the club usually check what the family prefare I think!

iv bin coming to the kc all but the 1st year it opend and normally its a good atmosphere up there.

I agree. It is not as respectful for the "old school" players, and seems a cop-out compared to a silence.

You can tell if people have contributed to a silence, but not if they have contributed to a "noise".

Poor decision IMO.

People just like to winge for the sake of it

But it takes effort and energy to make noise. A minutes silence is more a time to reflect. A minutes noise lets you show your emotion.

I would think a minute long rendition of old faithful as loud as the East West and South stands can sing would be a great honour for Arthur's family and get the blood going!!