I have given the him plenty of stick lately, last night he was much improved. Keep it up lad.

Sadly too little, too late.

To be honest, looked brilliant for the first few minutes, but after that he was mostly invisible! Could possibly be the most frustrating player we have EVER signed!

cant agree more with you.

Another player who definitely should not be here next year if we are to move up to being play off contenders

went pretty well at warrington too... the lad deserves some credit. had some terrible injuries but he has come back and made a go of things in tough times...

Played ok, still not super league standard. We must aquire better players than this in the near future

If he wasn't an overseas player I would be tempted to keep him as a back up player for next year but in the squad that it looks like we are putting together for next year I don't think he would be worth a quota spot.

I must say that now he is fit and getting a run of games I think he has shown a fair bit and some of the stick he got early on may have been a bit harsh.

Not seen enough bye bye for me. Good luck to him though.

Smith was one of out best players last night, and it was the best game I have seen him have. Unfortunately though he has burned his bridges in my opinion and there is no place for mediocre to poor overseas journeymen with us or even in the game as a whole.

Is he on a 1 or 2 year deal

He needs to be played more that's the problem. he has hardly been played this season and has shown great promise in the reserves as well as the games he has featured in

We should be offloading him for the same reason that Salford did last season - flashes of half-decent play are just not good enough to justify a quota spot.