I totally agree with your points but especially the part saying when we learn to play of him. He continually drew 3 and more players so this will create the gaps for the quicker men to exploit and with better conditions ahead his offloads should come off. I really did think he tried to hard in conditions not suitable but I am looking forward to seeing him again.

Wasn't there on friday away on holiday - was he really that bad ? as this seems to contradict some of the other posters on here ?

Have heard he may have an injury that may keep him out thursday - which could leave us very short of forwards - am hoping that Kirmond and /or tupou are available as without them we have lacked a leader in the pack.

It was a perfect storm - a big, aggressive, enforcer type prop, trying to make his mark in a new team; comes up against awful conditions and James Child, who loves the sound of his own whistle.

Feel for the bloke - he'll be filthy on himself, as I believe they say in Aus; or spewing, as Mr Kear said after the controversial Mr Cobb denied Batley a big win over Bradford.

1 it wasn't on our line it was at least 20 meters out 2 that was the only time he run sideways 3 it was taking 4-5 players to bring him down so hardly running under is weight 4 England dropped the ball more times then him 5 i never seen him back into contact once so if your going to bag someone at least tell the truth

on the clubs 'famous video player' channel, the highlights are on which include JJB arm in Fifitas face.

Is David Fifita injured then? Thought club may have announced it to influence RFL with JJB's 'legal' tackle

Oh my lord, the very definition of keyboard warrior.

Please don't dismiss me as a keyboard warrior....but he did have a 'mare

There's a difference between calling it as it was and calling a player names from a laptop in your mums back bedroom.

the reasons he wasn't playing nrl where their for all to see- he wont be around next year - so he will be only playing meanlingless games- this signing will offer us nothing.

I've just got back from a holiday in Australia and whilst there spoke to a couple of rugby league supporters about us signing David Fifita and they both said that they thought he would go well in England and is a decent signing and once he's up to speed would probably go well.

No guarantees I know but it's just another opinion to counter yours.

Fifita hasnt had a look in as Cronullas forwards have been in great form as the whole team has too. He had an infected knee this year which has obviously been a set back for him.
The main reason he has come over is to help his older brother who seems to be suffering from depression from injuries. He did the same with Andrew after a whole load of pressure was mounted on his shoulders - I reapect that.

On Friday yes he may have not had a great game, but he was the most effective out of the others and the others also made the same or more mistakes than him and I personally saw enough from him to see once he is settled that he'll become good for us even if he is only here for the rest of the season. If your thinking that hes only here on other business I saw a whole load of effort from him which would say otherwise - he wasnt lazy in attack or defence give the bloke a chance.....

That's exactly how I saw it....give the guy chance to find his feet and I think he will go well for us.

What's the alternative Yates or Walker?

Has he done a Ferres or Carney to you missus because you only seem to have negative things to say about the guy.

I reckon he'll do for me !!!

Jake Connor needs to have a word with himself squaring up to Fifita

Fat feet will do just fine ...

Lol at the clowns writing him off after one game...said he could be devastating for us once he settled in...it was obvious last week what he could bring to us...to anyone with a functioning pair of eyes!

The guys a beast, simple as that. Needs to watch his enthusiasm when he's on a high though.

What a performance it's been from Fifita - finally he looks like his brother. A tackle bust machine, strong runner, offload king. If he tidies up the penalties and tackle technique you lot could have made a top signing there.

I think Vastman was right....he could well be the one!

Well that's another own goal then for the Keyboard warriors!
Some of the comments about him after ONE game were just plain juvenile and bloody stupid.

Dont know why he got stick after leeds game and tonight he proved it wrong

I think this needs pinning as the all time dumbest post in history!!!