Apart from the knock on what has he done wrong?

Aydin! You’d have had a point with some players but Aydin is as far off ready as you can get.

If we are adopting a new strategy without relegation I have not noticed it nor have I spotted second phase football. It currently looks pretty much the same, maybe even worse and we should take Johnson off he is currently injured and could be doing more damage.
I really do hope for a better second half because this is currently the dullest game so far.

You’re joking! Try using the proper question...

... what’s he done right?

We surely can't be as bad again 2nd half. Cut out the errors and we have a chance. Wigan started well but we at least matched them the last 20.

Missed an easy goal
Dropped the ball in a key attack
Out of position for resulting try

And the fact I can't say anything else tells you the rest.

First game so tough for him but we need more.

Thought Josh was head and shoulders in fact both hookers, why are we trying to force the pass. Like Pop says Wigan aren’t playing that good but I’m afraid of Lamby geeing them up for the second.

I think it was more to do with us dragging them down to our level. I think they began to realise that we had nothing and got sloppy.

Not making enough yards and not enogh time in the Wigan half. Kicking game pants not turned the full back once. Second half try swaping full back and scrum half round.

Attack still as dire as it was five months ago.

Shocking performance , some worse than others . Very disappointing , let’s hope we can restore some pride .

That try was short by about 4 inches.

Our attack is an absolute embarrassment.

I could be wrong but does Phil Clarke have any connection with the Wigan organisation

Absolutely shocking ends to our sets. Compare it to Salford who are below us.

When is a no try a try when you wear a Wigan shirt today.

As ever you spoke too soon, you never learn do you.

That easy conversion which hit the post. Is the difference between 2pts and nowt.

We have a lot of improvement to make in attack but we were hard done to there with a couple of decisions.
We gave it away though. Not the refs fault.

Funny how a game lasts more than a twenty minute period.

Tony Gigot goal kicking was a big disappointment. I think he really cost us.

I know it’s not the refs fault but why didn’t we play from the start like we did at the end. This is not the first time we have tried to comeback after conceding large leads.

Max showed what a good goalkicker he is at the end, think he should have been given the job after Gogot hit the post with a fairly easy one. All ifs and buts now but hard to take when you lose by one again, that's twice already this season.

Gigot

I consider that thats one we should have won
I just wish we could get the on the field decisions right.
Kicking from hand was poor with one exception and the goal kicking pants.
We always seem to play at half speed and do not run enough from play the ball.