All the best Scott to the future and thanks for the service to our club in your two stints with us.

Hopefully some of your professionalism and experience has rubbed off on our younger full backs

Most significant single error since the famous Watersplash miss maybe?

Presumably you also have a massive agenda against David Fifita for knocking on at the PTB at Warrington with 2 minutes left and a two point lead? Or any player who made an error in any other game we lost by only a few points?

err....... No.

It will be stored in his memory bank for the appropriate moment.

All the best from me too Scott. You did the club proud in both your stints. Best wishes for the future.

Well how is Grix's error against Saints any different to Fifita's against Warrington? Yet you never stop whinging about the Grix one. Is he sleeping with your wife or something?

Timing, significance and uniqueness to that player.

I was responding to another poster as I rarely, if ever, whinge about it. However, it will remain, as does the Watersplash final, indelibly imbedded within my soul.

I think the main thing to remember is Grix did way more right for us than wrong and we should be appreciative of that.

But it is referenced in your sigs every time you post.

I guess you could argue the difference is that Grix's mistake resulted directly in a try.

Fifitas, although inevitably resulting in costing the game, did involve others who were also then at fault too for not controlling tackles, miss reads in defence etc.

You mean like all those people stood in front of Grix in the Sts game?

All those people did their job which resulted in Saints having to put a very poor kick through as a last resort.

no it wasn't, Dons missed kick cost us the cup without doubt, Grixs missed attempt to knock the ball out cost us a game which we probably wouldn't of gone further on in the play offs

both was human error that could and should be forgiven neither would of wanted it but it happened, yes sigh over it and think what if.
it will always stick in my mind Neil talking about his brother never being the same, we talk about mental heath issues and how we should address them yet we still try in ingrain mistakes on the players they will never forget.

been a good player for us on both occasions

Yes it was. If you read my comments, I wasn't comparing the two incidents nor the individuals, merely the significance

I challenge anyone to recollect and then tell me of a single individual error during the period between Don Fox's in 1968 and Grix's in 2017 of greater or even similar significance.

Sideshow Bob in the cup semi final at the Keepmoat against Hull. I recollect him making more than one significant error in that game.

not taken long to prove it

Glad he as gone ,was not that good first time round. As stop Jowitt or Hampshire developing . The Brough signing is interesting is he going to be used in 20 -30 mins, bursts . Still think he as more to offer than Finn .Not having a go at Finn .

I find it interesting that a player is not allowed to be human. We all make mistakes - some more than others - in all parts of life. I know that players are professionals and paid to make as few errors as possible but show me a player that has not made some errors. I bet all those complaining have made mistakes at work and they are being paid to do a job as error-free as possible. When those mistakes happen also reckon they really appreciate it when they others help sort out the mess rather than just criticising. Sometimes sh*t just happens.

Who cares, we've all moved on except you that is

He goes with my thanks and best wishes - he's been a big part of what WT has achieved during his tenure, and it's clear he's given his all when on the pitch.

Fair play - a proper pro, a great player and a thoroughly decent guy.

Possibly but we did get back to 18 - 16 by halftime and Broughy missed quite a few goal attempts so definitely better opportunities to still recover.

I always thought Chris Feather's loose carry about 18 minutes past 8 on Friday October 1st 2004 was the most costly error until Grix's. We were bringing the ball out at 14 nil up in the play offs and Wigan were rocking but they got possession and scored off the set. So close to progression to the elimination final as it was then called. Wigan got on a roll and we didn't score again.

Apologies, I misunderstood the challenge. I thought you meant any player not just players whose surname started with 'G', ended in 'X', with 'R' & 'I' in the middle

Accepted.

so you seem to remember every bad about mistakes in past games why not look to what was good about these players instead or can you not think of any