if true i dont care hes a sicknote have we ever had more than a 3rd of a season out of him

So you'd rather have a full season from a poor player or a third from a good one.

Really is a silly argument. The bulk of his sick note time was due to a career threatening knee injury. The rest was more to do with Kear not picking him. What's happening now is probably politics. I'd love to keep George but I think his fate was sealed when we all thought we were out of SL and there is the real culprit.

5 yr deal ?

Any player who can get a 5 year deal should snap it up, don't know if its true but Luke should take it if its offered.

there giving them away at shuddersfield like sweets

Are you confusing contracts with season tickets?