he would be last on my list, in order the list would be

luititi to me now exists on reputetion alone, and wont be cheap
mellors, to any one, just to get some cash back
lee smith, see ali reason, although prefer him to sykes!
fox, really dont know why some trinity fans still love the badge kisser


then ollie wilkes unfortunately, good season in my ooinion but rumours of a big wage bill

and then aiton, and that one hurts vos i really like him, but hooker fairly easy to cover?

bow to your greater knowledge of the game, just an accountants view!!!

If Addy has signed as been rumoured and him at Loose Forward would take pressure off of Timmy because he has a great kicking game IMO.

If this is anything to go by www.superleague.co.uk/player/10873 he needs to cut down on the missed tackles. Super Leagues leading tackle misser (is that a word????) www.superleague.co.uk/stats

If this is anything to go by www.superleague.co.uk/player/10873 he needs to cut down on the missed tackles. Super Leagues leading tackle misser (is that a word????) www.superleague.co.uk/stats

Wasn't mellars a winger at Crusaders. Is he worth a punt ahead of Fox.

You are right to laugh at that statement as it is indeed incorrect
It should have read "an average coach would have us in the top 6"
We have good players underperforming for a poor coach.

I don't agree
As an example, one of our better players, in Lee Smith, couldn't get a game with the Leeds reserves.
Mathers was let go by Cas, Cockayne was kicked out by HullKR (admittedly not for football reasons) Leeds didn't want Amor, Kirmond was let go by Huddersfield......they could all have been retained.
Even Tim Smith was struggling to play first grade. Only the bottom teams in Super League were interested.

We as a club and the current and previous coach in some cases made them into a good team.
We have hardly got a team of all talents that could just walk in the top 6.

I do however think we are are at the top end of the group below that and we could, with some stability and a couple of additions make it into that group as Hull KR are doing.