I am finding this a toughy, from what I can remember Andy King was real quality but wasn't with Cougars very long (a season?), Simon I had terrific defence and Matt was just consistently good even when Cougars were poor. And then there was Pinkney.....

These all depend on what boat your in

Either players who are great cougar players meaning being great players for Keighley the payers that top any list in means of people who have played for Keighley for a long period of time and even off field effect too

If that's the case then Foster wins easy

But the other hand is Great Rugby league players who have played for Keighley

In that case King & Pinkney win every time

I assume the Austin vote was a protest or a joke.

Nick Pinkney was just awesome, I will never forget that try he scored against Warrington and when you watch it back on the TV the guy commentating is loosing his voice, he's that into it and, "Jonathan Davies wipe my boots" I think is probably the most iconic line from that era, I remember when I would train with the Cougar Cubs, the amount of times someone would say that after scoring a try.

I thought Andy King was a class as well, it's a shame he didn't stay at the club longer.

Nick Pinkney and Andy King are your centres and join Andre Stoop, John Wasyliw and Jason Critchley in the team. Now open is the stand off vote, closes next Sunday.