Hardaker
Davies/Manfredi
Hankinson
Gildart
Marshall
Williams
Sammut
Flower
Leuluai
Tautai
Greenwood
Isa
O’Loughlin

Escare
Bullock
Hamlin
Kibula

We need a kicking game hence Sammut, Leuluai's a better 9 than Powell and sorry but Powell will offer nothing off the bench.
Might seem tough on Sarge especially considering that was probably Gildart's worst performance in a Wigan shirt but when he made that break in the second half if he'd looked to his left after the first two strides he could and should have put Marshall away.
Clubb/Naverette have been invisible and with Taylor missing for Hull seems like a good game for Kibula.

Still undecided about Powell or Tommy. I think what Powell offers in D is vastly underrated, might be only be visible when he's not there.

how does sarge get dropped after yesterday??

Tommy's a year past his sell by date.

Both our centres are simply not good enough. I still don't know what all the hype is regarding Gildart. Our centres are clones of each other, both have a good step, have pace, but both are unable to put a winger away and neither can tackle for toffee.

Gildart is one of the best in the league at putting his winger away. He managed to put Davies in well yesterday

Agreed. We have 2 good centres at Wigan.

He'll need to put him away more than just once a game to make up for that pathetic, filthy defence he showed yesterday. He should be dropped and given the rounds of the kitchen he was so bad. Play Hankinson instead.

Sammut in at 7, Tommy at 9 and Powell/Escare on bench. Gildart needs to go back to the left imo and if that means Sarge is dropped then so be it, we shouldn't be re jigging our best centre because the mediocre one feels comfortable on the left

Agreed he was awful and I haven’t seen him play that bad ever before but shouldn’t be dropped for one bad performance. If that’s the case we’d nearly be in double digits of players dropped just this season

I think he should for the simple reason that we have a replacement. We need to send a message that such awful defence wont be tolerated, it was some of the worst one on one tackling ive ever seen and Tommy should also be given a rollicking. I can live with one bad tackle but one after the other like that is criminal.

Not sure which games you have watched or which centres that you liken him to but I have yet to see him play as a centre that has frequently worked in u is on with his winger.

Hardaker
Marshall
Gildart
Sarginson
Davies
Williams
Sammut
Flower
Leuluai
Bullock
Greenwood
ISA
O’Loughlin

Clubb
Tautai
Powell
Partington

I would swap ISA for Hamlin

Hardaker
Davies
Hankinson
Gildart
Marshall
Williams
Sammut
Bullock
Tommy
Flower
Hamlin
Greenwood
Lockers

Bryne
Clubb
Kibula
Powell

Hardaker
Davies
Hankinson
Sarginson
Marshall
Williams
Sammut
Bullock
Powell
Flower
Hamlin
Greenwood
Lockers

Bryne
T T
Kibula
Powell

Hardaker,
Davis, Gildart, Sarginson, Marshall,
Williams, Sammut.
Flower, Powell, Clubb,
Isa, Greenwood,
O'Loughlin.

Bullock, Escare, Tautai, Kibula.

Sammut has to come in the improve our kicking game and provide George with some room to play. Sticking with Clubb and Gildart although both had poor games v Sydney. We can't make too many changes so TT has come in with Kibula who could be spelled with Lockers. Samy would probably only play 10-15 minutes each half.

So would I mate, I thought I’d included Hamlin but obviously had a brain fart!

I wouldn’t make changes to the 3/4’s, Gildart had a poor first half but blaming that on him playing on the right is nonsense imo. He’s had plenty of good games on the right most notably in the GF.

I agree with most, it’s time to bring Sammut in. We need a better kicking game both out of hand and off he tee. I’d start Sammut & Williams in the halves, TL at Hooker and Powell on the Bench. Powell can be used to spell TL & SOL throughout the game.

Just to clarify people are saying we should drop the current international centre who has been outstanding the last few years and Sarg who had one of his best ever games in a Wigan shirt for Hull?!

The only outside back under pressure should be Davies who has struggled in my opinion this year so far.

Sammut in the halves, Powell to continue at 9 and Tommy who is a bit more dynamic off the bench.

Yup id go with that.

Isa should be nowhere near the team. Play Tautai there to add some strike power and size.

I always think Isa is better when he starts rather than coming off the bench

Hardaker
Marshall Sarg Gildart Davies (unless Manfredi is back then he should come in for Davies)
Williams Tommy
Narrarette Powell Flower
Greenwood Partington
Lockers
----------------------
Sammut Bullock Hamlin Kibula

Navarrete has been poor in all his games this season, I don't think he has the "engine"
I wouldn't play Partington in the 2nd row, I don't think he's mobile enough. If you want to play one of the young players there then I'd go for Paisley or Kilner, but as hengirl says I'd probably start Isa.

There maybe a doubt about Sarginson, he looked to have a hand injury when he came into the South Stand bar for the post match discussion.