[urlhttp://www1.skysports.com/rugby-league/news/12216/8813969/Challenge-Cup-Gareth-Ellis-may-be-banned-for-Hull-s-quarter-final[/url

Grade B offence (the offence is unspecified anywhere, as far as I can see)...he's eligible for an early guilty plea though.

I'd probably play an extra forward on the bench anyway tbh. He was poor Friday night and hasn't offered much from the bench all season. He was very good playing the 80 minutes at Widnes and Wire and looks a solid full game player but we lose momentum when he comes from the bench.

If not an extra forward I'd put Hampshire or Powell on there.

Adds no value to the team whatsoever.

your joking? he ran Sam Powell close for mom at Widnes.

as other posters point out, hes not a "off the bench impact player", but he does offer something. Maybe we could start with him , and bring MM on after 15/20 mins as the impact player?

I think I'd just rotate between McIlorum and Tomkins now until the play offs to keep MM fresh. He's played less minutes this year anyway but it'll be nice to have him fit and firing for the play offs.

McIlorum to play against Widnes and Saints then Tomkins to get a game against HKR the following week for me. We can then continue to rotate after that.

Maybe if you watched him play in a game you might have a different opinion.

Thought he had a good game v Wire the other week too. May as well submit an EGP and get it out of the way.

Hampshire to the bench for me, he had a good game last week while Green had a very poor one so it would be good to have that option. I'd have Powell but he's disappointed me defensively against Widnes and Wire, looked to be a real target.

Was top tackler in the Widnes game as well as scoring the opening try and top tackler in the wire game with an impressive 45 tackles but yet he offers no value?????

Maybe going as a tag along in Sams deal?

what cover do we have?

If that did happen I'd imagine we'd go with Hampshire/Powell/Williams coming off the bench at 7 with Smith alternating between 7 and 9 as Leuluai used to do

I don't believe some of the comments on this thread.
I think Logan has to be one of the most exciting young hookers around at the moment.

His defensive effort is amazing and he distributes the ball well. If he can be coached as to when to take the ball up from dummy half and make metres that way, he could develop into something really special.

Don't know about the disciplinary, but only plead guilty, if guilty. Otherwise fight it off to keep a clean record.

1 match ban for making dangerous contact on Michael Platt.

Rouges What as happened to Carberry I thought he was goin to be our future no.9

Carberry in my opinion was a better number 9 than Logan but he got shunted to loose forward to accommodate him. This affected his game and he wasn't as effective at 13. Unfortunately he then suffered a bad injury and I think (not 100% sure) he will be out of contract before coming back.

You guys crack me up, WTF has he done? What about defending him? who needs enemies with "supporters" like you? I watch Wigan getting CLOGGED week in week out with no action taken, why is it just accepted that Wigan players are fair game? It's a joke!

must of been serious if ellis got away with the shoulder to the head and tomkins has been banned for dangerous contact.

I don't remember the incident at all, but since he's gone for the EGP I guess he must have done something...

Go have a lie down and a cup of tea mate.

He got a bad injury (knee?) playing for South Wales. I'm not sure where he is up to in his rehab or if he'll play again this season.