Might have been done to death so apologies if so, however, do you think he will ever feature for wigan again? I see great potential in him. Not great defensively but that speaks for the whole squad at the moment. Bags of pace and I would love to keep him

not in the first team

I don't think he'll come back myself. I've always thought he plays too much with blinkers on.

Same here. A winger not a centre.

This.

Even less chance now that Thornley and Gelling will take preference.

Had potential but he rarely seems to pass the ball at the right times. He's got bags of pace which is a bonus but I always thought he'd do better as a winger. I think it would be a shame if he left Wigan without having been tried on the wing but the coaches will know best.

Gelling has been brought in to play either centre or wing and we have now just re-signed Thornley, a centre.
Can't see Marsh at Wigan again as he is OOC at the end of this season.

That would be my view and hopefully Widnes can get him snapped up.

Has formed a decent partnership with Flynn all in all that could grow well together over time. Has scored some good individual tries and did set up a few for Paddy early doors, though not as many lately

Agreed. Pretty sure Widnes will sign him now. Thornley was always a better player than him at Academy level.

He scored a classy try at the weekend. He has bags of pace but he often doesn't use it wisely enough.

Yep. It always seemed to me that he never adapted to the higher standard of defences at SL level. He scored cracking solo tries for fun against Academy defences, and got used to being greedy?

Goulding was the same. Look how he has turned out, these things take time. Some players take a little longer to develop. The pace of marsh used in the right way would be a devastating weapon.

Goulding made his Wigan debut in 2005 and we only started to see any return on the time we invested in him in 2010 and after a quiet spell he has been one of the top centres in the league this year and looks like nailing the number 3 shirt for years to come at just 23/24 years of age.

Comparing Marsh to Goulding is like comparing chalk and cheese. Goulding was always highly rated, represented England at every age level and was the number 1 centre at his age group. Marsh has never been this sort, or calibre, of player. Also Goulding may have made his debut in 2005 but people forget that he had only just turned 17 and that he broke a bone in his foot in this debut and missed the rest of the season. He was then treated abysmally by Noble in the following years, along with some other young players, and never got any sort of run of games before being made a scapegoat, usually unfairly.

Goulding has never been greedy either and the way he is playing now is much the way that he played in the academy. People seem to have levelled this accusation in the past because his winger didnt get the ball much, whilst completely ignoring the fact that he very rarely got the ball himself due to the ball stopping once it got to Phil Bailey and because of our style of play at that time. Marsh on the other hand as always been a greedy so and so and doesnt know how to pass. Even in the try he scored at the weekend, which was very poor defence by McGoldrick as much as anything, there was a point where he had created the overlap and should have passed to his winger but didnt.

I couldnt see Marsh being here next year and definately cant now with the signing of Thornley.

He's better than Chris dean and willie isa so that will do for me

cant see him in a Wigan shirt to be honest. We have very little cover in his position but he was sent out on loan , that speaks volumes IMO

Marsh is a good athlete but not a good rugby player