I used do this years ago and I'm bringing it back. A simple idea you list the things to praise about the performance and whats making you grumble.

For me

Praise: Thought the pack was reasonably solid. Love the Ginger Pearl!

Grumble: Kicking Game obviously. As I wrote in my report we didn't get enough from 6,7,9 and 13 positions to win compared to that of Huddersfield. The full back and three-quarters thus had miserly scraps to feed off.

Match Report is here btw: [url=http://wigan.rlfans.com/news.php?readmore=1145=#FF0000wigan.rlfans.com/news.php?readmore=1145[/url

Praise - Hard to see any positives.


Grumble - No co -ordination in the backs, out fought by a weakened Giants pack - No kick,kick,kicking game

Praise - We did attempt to spread the ball, Finch had a lot of possession, we should get much better as the season goes on.

Grumble - Wane's hard line approach, he's an old school coach who expects to win every week, with this squad it isn't possible. If i hear him use the word 'tough' and ''hard taskmaster' again il scream.

Praise:
Forwards ran hard all afternoon & mostly tackled/defended well.

Grumble:
Our kicking game



Good attacking plays coming to nowt after a loose pass or the ball going to ground

No pressure being put on Danny Brough every time he kicked meaning he had time to pick his spot

Four forwards on the bench meaning the team having to shuffle in order to accommodate Tommy going to 9 (where he should be)

Praise - we didnt get flogged. We'll improve.

Grumble - we were poor

Praise - first game of the season no need to panic

Grumble - We looked so rusty why are we only playing 2 warm up games when we have a tough start to the season

Praise - Mossop showed again he'll be the pack leader, and Farrell's angled runs are a joy to watch.

Grumble -The non-existent kicking game, lack of effort at times, Leuluai playing at 7 when he's never, ever, ever a Scrum Half.

Praise - Mossop, Lima and Farrell all had decent games. We showed in glimpses that we're willing to play a bit of rugby.

Grumble - We looked really rusty and short of match practice. I'd put this down to too few preseason games for our first team.

Praise - Farrell's contribution.

Grumble - Pre-season was obviously a completely mishandled as the players looked unfit and not used to playing as a team.

The players outside Finch are just not smart enough to make something of the passes he puts away. He is on a different level to the rest of the outside backs.

Pat looks to have lost too much pace to carry on as a winger for much longer (unless improved match fitness gains him a couple of yards).

The new signings are simply not as good as the players that have left.

Kicking game would shame an amateur side.

Positives:
Lima, Mossop and Hansen ran very well. Harrison Hansen really has kicked on in these last few years. Liam Farrell runs some excellent lines too - the only forward to come on with any impact. Gaz Hock proved a handful on occasions too.

When Leuluai moved to hooker we looked a different side. TL must play at hooker!

When we did execute our plays, I thought we troubled Huddersfield and we scored with no-one laying a finger on any of our players.

Negatives:
Forwards coming off the bench - Flower/Lauaki/Tuson - didn't have much impact on the game at all. Tuson to be fair didn't have much time on the field, but they struggled for me. Looking forward to the return of Prescott/Fielden.

Mike McIlorum. Not convinced this lad is up to it. He just does not offer enough in attack. We looked a different side when Leuluai moved to hooker.

Kicking game. Leuluai cannot kick. His best position is without doubt at hooker. I wouldn't move Lockers out from 13, instead I would give Powell/Mellor a go. I accept they're inexperienced, but around Sam Tomkins, Brett Finch, Thomas Leuluai and Sean O'loughlin they'll have a top quality/world class 1, 6, 9 and 13 for support. Isn't Sam Powell's main strength his kicking game? He'll be getting a game sooner or later.

[uPraise[/u
- Faz
- Mossop and Lima doing the work of 4 props because they didn't get any help yesterday (Fielden and Prescott can't come back soon enough)

[uGrumble[/u
- The worst kicking game in SL by some distance, calling it appalling would be giving it far too much praise. The Lamb and Flag 2nd XIII would have been embarrassed.
- We've got the slowest three-quarter partnership in SL on our left hand side.
- The huge gaps left up the middle for Shudds to exploit, and from which they scored all their tries.
- The fact Shudds wanted it more.

Praise: - Liam Farrell, always looks like he's got a break in him, deceptively quick as well. Should always make the bench ahead of Flower/Tuson when Prescott & Fielden are back.
Hansen was good as well, ran hard, looks like he might have put a bit of size on.

Grumble:- Kicking game, shambolic. Brough won Hudds the game by pinning us back.
We look slow and laboured with McIlorum at 9. Yes he's rock solid in defence but we need more going forward in such a key position(Roby, Monaghan). If he's playing 50/60 minutes every week we're gonna struggle to break the better sides down.

And that's the worst part of it all - no Wigan side should ever be guilty of that.

Praise: the forwards, mostly. And the attendance - over 16k home supporters (plus maybe 500 Giants fans?) is a good sign (hope the performance didn't put off the "floaters" for future games)

Grumble: the lack of a kicking game, and the midfield defence.

Praise - Hock was great in attack at times. Lima was better than last year. Farrell looks like he did in 2010. The new boys went ok.

Grumble - No kicking game. In 2011 we played a slightly worse version of what we did in 2010. Now in 2012 we are playing a slightly worse version of what we did in 2011. We are far too predictable in attack. We don't move the ball half as quick as we used to in 2010, this is a grumble from last year as well.

Wane has said he wants the players bigger and faster and more skillfull, I don't think that really works. It showed at the game. We were not building pressure like we used to. We need a massive improvement.

We havn't lost 2 in a row during a season since 2009 when we got beat by saints away through a late Eastmond try and then got beat by Wire in the cup semi a week later. I am proud of that record. We need to improve bigtime if we are to beat Leeds next week.

Praise: as most have said the forwards performed well especially Lima and Mossop

Grumbles: we play one of the most dangerous players in the world in a position where he is out of the game for a large majority
we play a world cup winner hooker who cannot kick in a position where he has to kick
we move the entire team around to accomodate tommy at hooker and have the loose forward move to stand off.

WHY WHY WHY WHY WHY

why do we see it and the professionals cannot!!!!!!

Praise-Rugby League is back!

Grumble-Wane has tried to fix/alter something that wasnt broke rather than slowly making subtle changes. Its well known John Dorahy tried to do it in the 90's and as the season went on the players started to ignore him and play the way that had worked for them for many years.

Praise
Last 10 mins showed what we are capable of.
Faz's runs are formidable
Hock showed glimpses of what he used to be

Grumble
No desire - the way some of the lads dragged themselves to pack down 10 metre off our line towards the end was embarrasing.
Paddy's lost his speed since his injury
K I C K I N G G A M E

Praise - Farrell's angled runs are quality. Hansen hit hard and ran good lines. Mossop and Lima look good.

Grumble - As many have said, lack of ANY kicking game. No intensity in attack or defence (until it was too late). Silverwood!

It's early doors yet. Surely if we can point out the problems, our coaching staff can do the same.

Praise - Starting forwards

Grumble - Kicking game

Praise - Mossop and Lima were outstanding. Lima worked very hard and Mossop was very effective running the ball.
Farrell looks like he could be in for a very good year. His support play is excellent and he looked stronger in defence.
Hock was erratic but there are promising signs. He was making metres for fun and missed too many tackles but considering his 5 match ban will have affected his return to match fitness he's looking promising.

Negatives - Our two new props were nothing short of poor. Flower worked hard in defence but ruined it with some sloppy tackling. In attack he was almost non-existent and couldn't make any impact against a weakened Giants pack.
Lauaki was worse, he didn't do anything with ball in hand, made very few metres and seemed completely reluctant to make a tackle.
Lack of invention in attack at times. The dummy runners weren't drawing players in down the middle, the passing wasn't slick.
Carmont and Richards looked surprisingly poor. Richards seems to have lost any pace he once had while Carmont wasted several opportunities. He's only had 1 pre-season game though so perhaps he can be forgiven for not being up to scratch.

Praise: Mossop, Lima, Hansen good going forward. Flower good defensively at one point made 4 tackles in a row. Generally forwards ok but didn't make the 'dents' I expected will get better though IMO. We didn't play well but still could have won!

grumbles: kicking game woeful, organisation poor particularly on last tackle.

Praise- ginger pearl was awesome

Grumble- kicking game non exisitant

This sums it all up very well for me. In addition our kicking game leaves a lot to be desired, for the umpteenth season in a row

Praise - Farrell, Mossop and Lima

Grumble - Everything else was utter rubbish