Did anybody else notice last night that he had to stop him self saying that he couldn't believe that George Carmont got into the dream team ahead of Ryan Atkins!

I noticed.

George Carmont is the best centre in super league.

Atkins/Bridge 'could' have been in ahead of Yeamon though.

Atkins seems to be doing his England chances no harm.

I've not heard him ask if Warrington are the 'real deal' all season, he asked that about us every game until the Grand Final.

im a bulls fan and I think that atkins or bridge should have been ahead of carmont

i wonder what this thread will turn into......

[size=150O
=======D
O[/size

________________
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
"""""""""""""""""""""""
________________




As a guess...

If it does, ANYONE who contributes to another weeing contest will be taking a break (and I might conveniently forget to put a time limit on them). I'm fed up moving childish posts and locking threads last night and today as yet another Wigan/Wire thread brings out the infant in some.

There's been plenty of warnings, there won't be anymore.

I still don't understand why some fans get so wound up by what he says

Eight? Is that all you've got?? Sheesh..

What does Eddie Hemmings know about RL anyway?

Absolute feck all.

A combination of McBanana coaching and Atkins in the centres is a frightening prospect this autumn.

Eddie Hemmings is just a Wigan hater simples , he bums up everyone BUT Wigan , i remember not long back when the Sam Tomkins booing started he more or less said that hed brought it upon himself.

On the centre situation , george is better . but wouldnt complain if RA had got in with the trys hes scored this season

Just looking at the stats as Phil Clarke would, you wouldn't have put Carmont ahead.

Atkins has more tries, try assists, tackle busts, clean breaks and he's missed fewer tackles than Carmont. He played 2 fewer games as well so his carries, meters and offloads might have got ahead too.

But Carmont is a better centre, i.e skill and natural ability Atkins is having a one off good season. Was he this good at Wakefield, NO and was he this good last year, NO. Carmont has been consistently good for WIgan since his arrival regardless of the fact some other centre have more tries, tackles, assists, tackle busts etc. He's also proven in Australia, the only thing Atkins proved in Australia was that he can't tackle.

atkins was just a young lad at wakefield and he is still learning and improving , aint that obvious

so you saying atkins aint good enough for a england shirt , can you name two better english centres

Yeaman and Bridge (IMO).

And Reed..

Hemmings= Tw*t (you can think twit if you like)

Yeaman, Bridge, Reed and Gleeson.

stats and performances tell a different story

I was looking at stats the other night and Ben Cross' stats are very similar to Adrian Morley's. Now what does that say. because stats suggest they are the same player!

And Roby's stats are far, far superior to M.Monaghan's but Warrington fans will claim stats don't show the full picture in that comparison.

Can not believe people get wound up by Eddie now. Its almost as old as Steveo.

As for the better centre of all the choice mentioned here. The scary bit of all is that the English centres mentioned for Engalnd none are good enough but due to the lack of real players of the ability in the squad at centres they will all get selected for the squad. Are some not disturbed that all centres in SL only 1 or 2 is as good as Carmont and yet you would not see Carmont in an OZ or NZ shirt now.

Carmont has been good for us this season. Thought he was a lot better last season though.

two completly different style of 9s and either of them would walk into any team in SL & possibly the NRL

yes, because Melbourne can't wait to get rid of Cameron Smith so they can sign the all-conquering Michael Monaghan..