John Wilkin/Greg Eastwood.

Given he still plays the game as a pro though the winner of the all time title has to be Robbie Paul.

Greg Eastwood
Leon Pryce
Ade Gardner
Matt Diskin
Chev Walker
Jamie Jones Buchanan

agree with wilkin, eastwood when he can be d is a real handful. we havnt seen that in SL but down under i always rated him.

modern day i have to say ade gardner. his career has been made on playing outside lyon and gidley. who wouldnt look good ????

Quite surprised to see references to Ben Harrison. Not the kind of player to merit a mention either way; not a flashy player at all. In fact, I don't recall him ever receiving any plaudits.

Worrincey is the worst player ever to play super league!

Wilkin is very very overrated.

JAMES GRAHAM OVERRATED!!!!!!! Got to be joke!

no joke pal , he's just not my kind of prop

i prefer the morley , fielden , peacock style

only my opinion of course , but i just see JG as a plodder , lets see how he goes in australia

[/u

St Pete I'd just ignore some of the idiots that post on here

Anyone who thinks he is overrated has either never seriously watched the game, is a complete wind up merchant or is so blinkered that they cant appreciate the quality players other team have

As a wigan fan would you really put Fielden in the same league as Morley and Peacock currently

much as I like Fielden at present not in the same class

absolutley , he's a 100%er every week

fielden and morley as my starting props , awesome

as for not recognising other teams players , do morley and peacock play for us ?

there are lots of players who play for other clubs who i rate and admire , JG just doesnt do it for me .

Personally I think Graham is by far the best prop in the league and maybe the best player too

Not your kind of prop!

I'm nit just saying this as a saints fan but graham is the perfect prop, he's big, strong, fast, awesome work rate, great in defence, good hands, makes more meters than any other prop in super league and has heart!

He's everything you'd want from a prop!

With all respect to stu fielden ( who I like) he ain't in the same league anymore as graham, peacock and mozza.

I find your post pretty funny to be honest, it's pretty obvious you don't watch rugby.

I agree with all of this if anyone thinks graham is average they need to sort there **** out

take away the mtrs when he passes the ball before hitting the line ?
i dont want that from my props , off load in the tackle yes , but i want them breaking tackles and taking the line on

dont get me wrong ,[u im not saying he's poor [/u, what im saying is he doesnt do it for me and the title is of the thread is 'over rated'

i prefer the impact 'style' props ie morley , fielden and peacock , JG is consistent , steady etc etc

And thats one of his main dangers teams dont know when he's passing or taking a hit up do you send 2-3 men at him then he passes theres an overlap or if they hang off he going 1 on 1

opinions , every body is entitled

Yeah i agree fella

Myler, Sinfield

Mcillorum

Cunningham.

Sinfield...still???? really!











He didn't need 3 attempts from the touchline.

He stayed with Rovers for 3 seasons keeping us in SL with his Performance against Salford and Hull in our 1st season. The financial punt from Rovers was worth every penny as without him we wouldn't have survived our 1st season in SL.