He has a short memory

Well he would know all about letting people down. Self serving bell end.

This.

That whole rant by Brian Carney shows how little he knows about the current crop of Wigan players.

why because he choose to move on from wigan, being a bit selfish aren't you

No and no. Do some research pal.

from what I can remember he was a model player unless something trivial was swept under the carpet, do educate me as I don't follow Wigan

Basically, agreed to join Gold Coast when his Wigan contract ended, begged for and was granted early release from Wigan to join Newcastle Knights, did a season with them then bailed on Gold Coast without ever playing for them to go to Irish RU before returning to RL with Warrington, hence self serving bell end.

so nothing sinister no drugs, no alcohol, as I thought just wanted to get away from Wigan to try the game in NRL and chose a different path

come on the way you was talking he'd done wigan over, he left early the rest is has nothing to do with his wigan contract while he was you and his reputation of being a model player, circumstances change and you can choose to change your mind, is it because he chose Wire than Wigan

what he has commented on is a complete disrespect to your club, using drugs, drink driving, drinking and causing a public nuisance, that's before you even mention your management

wonder how many of your fans have the same thought the he is a bellend?

It was the can't be d performances he produced in order to get an early release that ed many fans off iirc

There was another incident that I won't go into here but the police were involved. Far from a 'model' anything.

And post Wigan...

[urlhttps://www.theguardian.com/sport/2006/mar/14/rugbyleague.gdnsport3[/url

Quote ="Phuzzy"There was another incident that I won't go into here but the police were involved. Far from a 'model' anything.'" interesting but can't go further, as for https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2006/ ... .gdnsport3 I remember this one, was a nothing incident and a simple apology sorted it, rather than disgusting one with the tompkins and the now drugs episode what next as Carney said the truth will come out, there's more to it

Quote ="Phuzzy"There was another incident that I won't go into here but the police were involved. Far from a 'model' anything.'" interesting but can't go further, as for https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2006/ ... .gdnsport3 I remember this one, was a nothing incident and a simple apology sorted it, rather than disgusting one with the tompkins and the now drugs episode what next as Carney said the truth will come out, there's more to it

Quote ="snowie"eusa_think.gif interesting but can't go further, as for https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2006/ ... .gdnsport3 I remember this one, was a nothing incident and a simple apology sorted it, rather than disgusting one with the tompkins and the now drugs episode what next as Carney said the truth will come out, there's more to it'" You may be able to find something online if you're interested. It involved Frankie and Benny's In Wigan (allegedly! ) As for the Australian incident he was fined for it and was alleged to have assaulted the door staff so hardly a nothing incident unless you want to apply your own standards to suit your agenda. Incidentally the 'disgusting' Tomkins incident has some, shall we say, uncanny parallels with a certain incident that took place at Frankie and Benny's. No one is saying that things at Wigan are rosy at the moment... I even agree with some of the things he has to say. The point being made is more a 'people in glass houses' type than anything else. He's hardly been a paragon of virtue either in terms of his off field behaviour or in the way he's put himself before the club. Both things he's ranting about in this interview. Hypocritical, no?

Quote ="snowie"eusa_think.gif interesting but can't go further, as for https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2006/ ... .gdnsport3 I remember this one, was a nothing incident and a simple apology sorted it, rather than disgusting one with the tompkins and the now drugs episode what next as Carney said the truth will come out, there's more to it'" You may be able to find something online if you're interested. It involved Frankie and Benny's In Wigan (allegedly! ) As for the Australian incident he was fined for it and was alleged to have assaulted the door staff so hardly a nothing incident unless you want to apply your own standards to suit your agenda. Incidentally the 'disgusting' Tomkins incident has some, shall we say, uncanny parallels with a certain incident that took place at Frankie and Benny's. No one is saying that things at Wigan are rosy at the moment... I even agree with some of the things he has to say. The point being made is more a 'people in glass houses' type than anything else. He's hardly been a paragon of virtue either in terms of his off field behaviour or in the way he's put himself before the club. Both things he's ranting about in this interview. Hypocritical, no?

Oh, and on the 'drugs one'; if you think that drug taking is confined to the young men of Wigan may I politely suggest you are very naive. That said I'm pretty sure you're aware it's rife at every club and in every city and town, yours included. The only variable is who is stupid enough to get caught.

I’m less worried about the Wigan-born players in our squad than the non-Wigan born collective..

There’s more to come here I think.

Spot on. Bars/Clubs these days in the gents the queues for the cubicles are longer than the ones for the urinals (unheard of back in the 90's/early 00's)....you cant tell me they are all busting for a turd.

I've been to the last four Ladies Day at Aintree and it's absolutely rife, I was shocked a few years ago. Openly doing beak, no hiding in corners...gangs of lads, suited and booted, 2pm in the afternoon just tooting up off their finger & thumbs in front of their mates every few minutes as if they were swigging a drink of beer.

From that article

"Adrian Morley, the other Great Britain international in Australia, is also in hot water after being put on report for a high tackle on the former Leeds stand-off Ben Walker in Sydney Roosters' victory over South Sydney at the weekend. "I'm a tall bloke," Morley said in mitigation"







Moz, what a legend

Can't argue with his logic!

I have high regard for Carney as a presenter, though anyone is better than Wiggy. And I had very high regard for him as a player, though I think he's demonstrating Short Memory Syndrome here.

Skiving, malingering ... call it what you will, but the way he left us in that final year was nothing short of disgraceful. He talks about players showing disrespect to the Wigan fans and club. He ought to know.

Hypocrisy aside, is Carney correct, have players shown a disrespect to the club?

Personally, I think they're just being idiots.

I don't mean that exonerates them from blame, though.

Certainly, their actions are bringing embarrassment to the club, and great joy to the club's enemies. In addition, it leaves us in ethical messes, because what are we supposed to do: stand by them while they serve their bans, wasting money and salary cap space - when, as in the case of Hock, they might then go and throw it all in our face again? Or do what Cas did with Hardaker, and get rid straight away, and then maybe end up regretting it?

I doubt it was their intention to humiliate us this way, but the stupidity factor is very high - because anyone with half a brain would recognise that this outcome is always easily possible.

They've shown no respect for themselves
If I did the same it isnt a reflection on my employer, it's a reflection on me.
Petty points scoring about which club a player plays for is just an aside.

Warrington have started to turn their culture around, but as I am sure you will know 10 /15 years ago up until very recently it would be a case of "their for the grace of God" with a large proportion of those players.
I have friends, and other links to people who have played and have had other roles at wire and until very recently there was a lot of things going on, even under Smith. Let's just say there were lots of "Ups" & "Downs" amongst other things (and a certain well liked player at Wigan used to distribute them like smarties before he left so not just picking on wire here)

Price has vastly improved that, but they're not whiter than white same as EVERY club.

The question here is game wide, not just Wigan having 2 problems being caught in quick succession.
Because very soon it will be different players, different club's and although they may not get as much attention (Because it's Wigan) it doesn't detract from the issue.

Wigan do as much as any club if not more than most in educating youngsters coming through.
Just over 18months ago I was talking to a national coach of another sport who came down to speak to Shaun wane and look at the junior set up and he was blown away with everything from player recruitment, coaching and education and career path beyond rugby and said it was better than anything he had seen.

Only trouble is that creates other issues, you pamper them with all this extra stuff and they're likely to think there's always a get out clause and someone will help them.
However, that's better than the alternate of doing nothing.

End of the day though it's a nationwide issue and whether we think it is socially acceptable or not these days the game and it's players and officials need to understand that as long as we are following UKAD and WADA etc then that are of their social life WILL IMPACT on their chosen profession. If they want to continue with their habits then so be it, but they'll have to continue to dodge bullets and I won't feel sorry if they don't and get caught.

Wigan (Leneghan) provides a lot of support for players affected by a lot of issues and I reckon 75% of the issues goes on without the general public knowing about it. When it does become public the club have employer/employee responsibilities so it's not easy for them to explain what's gone on and how they've helped or disciplined the players/employees.

Majority of fans want a quick and simple response, we've sacked him for example but it's far far more complicated than that.
Educating players can only go so far, at some point they have to take responsibility for themselves (and no matter how much you tell some people, some learn quick some learn slow and some never learn at all).

Good responses. There's a very small difference I feel in players that give there all, and let themselves down with off field lifestyle choices, and the likes of Tyrone Roberts, who didn't want to be here with us (similarly Sandow). Either way, it's the clubs that suffer in the end with someone under-performing or having one less in the squad all of a sudden. I suppose it doesn't really matter what label we put on these players, but it's annoying to the spectator that pays their money and are repaid with such behaviour.

I know its rife everywhere Adam Walker at Wakey got 2 yr ban and sacked from Trinity for cocaine