I know we have our banter with Wire but thats a good side that and will come close to trophies again this year.

We should have a decent idea of where we're at after tomorrow night.

The only one to make that team stronger for me is bringing in Hicks on the wing instead of Riley. My concern is we are light on props if Carvell or Morley get injured or banned.

Paul Wood must be due a full season without injury but if he doesn't get that and like you say anything happens to either of those 2 it could lead to a period of struggle.

Overall though i'd say the first 17 at Wire is just about the joint 2nd strongest in the league along with St Helens.

Good team, But, I believe they only have the edge on us in the front row, IMO we are better in every position apart from that. Hopefully MM will pick us a strong team and we can have a proper full blooded match tomorrow.

If you could choose a mixed team of your 13 from both who would you pick?

We've had this loads of time haven't we and everytime Wigan fans come up with more Wigan players and Wire fans with Wire players.

Overall i'd say the teams are much of a muchness bar your starting front row is stronger. An honest fan would probably come up with a 9-8 split either way imo.

Phelps
Richards
Carmont
King
Bridge
Sam
Myler
Morley
Monagan
Fielden
Feka
Harrison Hansen
O'Loughlin

Interesting to hear peoples views though had some good banter on here last season.

I'll have a crack whilst i'm bored



Phelps- It's hard for us not to pick him after us watching both live last season. His form was very good in the 2nd part of the year.
King
Atkins
Carmont
Richards
S Tomkins
Briers- just ahead of Myler to kick and pass the side around the field
Carvell
Monaghan
Morley
Westwood
J Tomkins(i'd have Solomona if he were fully fit but i'm not sure)
O'Loughlin

subs
Paleaaesina
Prescott(just ahead of Wood because Wood has alot to prove injury wise)
Harrison
Leuluai

I have us 9-8 up overall but with wire having 7 in the starting line up and a full starting front row. That probably shows you'll be slightly ahead of us this year because games are won and lost in that front row.

Phelps
Ainscough
Gleeson
Carmont
Pat
Sam
Tommy
Morley
Monaghan
Feka
Hansen
Tomkins
O'loughlin

King has the talent to maybe pip Gleeson, But i'm allowed to be slightly biased, right? If we had your front row I think we'd have the best team in the league.

Of the 13 I would have Louis ahead of Joel, Myler ahead of Briers and if he was on his game at his best Gleeson ahead of Atkins.

I thought about Anderson but i've just never seen much of him over a consistant period to suggest he should be in. I don't watch him week in week out though so it's hard to comment.

It's fair to say it's a close call in a lot of positions though. Some blinkered fans will have 13 or 14 of their own players in but the more realistic will have it pretty much split.

Confirmed squads



2 very strong teams there.

Should be a cracker

I've started a new thread so we'll leave this one lying

[urlhttp://viewtopic.php?f=28&t=442573[/url