Bentham said when giving him the yellow "punching and hair pulling" Very disappointing that he refused the hand shake from LMS at the final whistle.

Yet straight after the Garbutt punch in the WCC you were starting a thread on the Leeds board saying....



Children watching tonight.....bang out of order, shameful, disgusting......do you know what one punch can do?

Spot on mate.

Being coached to run through a brick wall all day will only take you so far.

Little slap on the cheek but no punches tonight and no surprise top see a Leeds fan defending one of their players punching is their?

Saints won the game but there is no doubt that FPN won the confrontation.

One thing Saints lack is aggressive players and my Saints friends deep down know they would be in love with FPN if he was on your team and did that when you won. Hypocrites and he's already a Wigan legend.

I wouldn't worry too much the rugby league will look after you as they always do if locker can only get one match for that close line 2 weeks ago which put the Wakefield player out for the rest of the season tonight's bad discipline will only result in a 10 pound fine and go back to old Kent road the disciplinary are a fooking joke its probably all your old players on the panel, anyway Wane will have a moan again Soz but you can hardly moan can you

Really, do you actually believe that? Who do you think is the happiest coach with his player. I think Wane will have to have a word with FPN

As a wigan.fan i'm interested to know why he said saints dont have aggressive players.... i'd say LMS Amor and Walmsley were certainly aggressive players.

Where did I defend Garbutt? I said at the time red card and 2 match ban seemed fine.......just pointing out your hypocrisy



Will someone please just think of the children!

FPN already a Wigan legend. Worst comment I have ever seen from any fan of any sport.

Good game. Fully deserved our win

I think he meant already a Wigan thug ...
I would agree.

Saints deserved to win but a good game? Low quality so par for course in 2016.

Perhaps someone should tell him that when you get binned you have to leave the field cos the decision wont change

Perhaps someone should tell him that when you get binned you have to leave the field cos the decision wont change also Bateman should learn from past mistakes and keep his trap shut instead of winding players up. Nob ed

Damp squib more like, "wrecking ball" no, more like "wrecking off the ball". He only made one pass out of the tackle after struggling to make metres in the game. LMS sorted him out converted a so called big hulk into a Big Sulk, very poor sportsmanship not responding to a hand shake after the final whistle.

Talking of bins, shouldn't you be crawling back into yours

Only FPN out of those mentioned deserves a ban for me.

The Tomkins one looked bad at first but Fleming was falling and it was more instinctive than anything from Tomkins.

Penalty sufficient for the Isa and Crosby ones. The Crosby one actually came off the shoulder.

I don't like the cannonball tackles and a ban to Mossop wouldn't shock me but I've seen worse and he might just get off with it.

Haven't got a clue what FPN was playing at though. Hair pull, tackling a man without the ball and a half punch/half slap all within 60 seconds. Not made himself look good there at all.

I'd say that's pretty spot on on all incidents above.

The one I didn't like last night though and hasn't really been mentioned was Sarginson pushing Swift into the advertising boards, very unnecessary and reckless on his part and easily could've resulted in a bad injury for Swift if he ends up going over the boards.

Yeah you're right that wasn't good either. It was just completely needless and dangerous.

I think that is a fair and reasoned assessment. I didn't think that there was too much wrong with the Isa tackle. Sarginson was stupid, it was unnecessary but Swift did something similar on Tomkins in the 1st half.

Similar? Come on Brian haha. I'm sure even you couldn't have kept a straight face writing that.

I said all along, we bought the wrong Frank.

Can't see any bans there myself but I'm praying they don't ban fpn for Friday's semi

Hull sold 6500 tickets so far for Fridays game.

8000 or so attendance then, assuming we shift a few more before Friday